Table 2 Main statistics for Meta-analyses of dopamine subsystem dysfunction in schizophrenia by different PET markers.

From: Resolving the heterogeneity of dopamine subsystems dysfunction in schizophrenia: a PET meta-analysis

Marker

Region

Patients

NSCZ

NHC

Cohen’s d

 

Meta Z

Meta P

Q

Q-test p

I2(%)

I2[95%CI(%)]

Egger’s z

Egger’s p

Power

 

D2/3

 
 

STR

Total

277

313

0.41

 

1.91

0.056

159.37

8.25e-23

86.19

[80.53, 90.21]

1.18

0.236

0.999

 
 

STR

Drug Off

219

259

0.56

 

2.73

0.006

  

82.02

[72.97, 88.05]

  

1

 
 

STR

Drug Naive

97

108

0.77

 

2.16

0.031

  

87.98

[78.58, 93.25]

  

1

 
 

STR

Drug On

58

54

−0.36

 

-0.50

0.616

  

93.90

[87.56, 97.01]

  

0.471

 
 

THA

Total

193

209

−0.38

 

−2.14

0.032

46.37

1.23e-05

71.96

[51.97, 83.63]

−1.09

0.274

0.967

 
 

THA

Drug Off

162

162

−0.18

 

−1.46

0.144

  

37.97

[0.00, 68.02]

  

0.385

 
 

THA

Drug Naive

88

107

−0.26

 

−1.40

0.162

  

54.52

[0.00, 80.53]

0.45

0.650

0.436

 
 

THA

Drug on

31

24

−1.73

 

−3.49

4.75e-04

  

68.09

[0, 92.80]

  

1

 
 

LIB

Total

103

104

−0.41

 

−1.42

0.157

32.37

1.38e-05

81.47

[62.74, 90.78]

−0.66

0.509

0.835

 
 

LIB

Drug Off

72

80

−0.03

 

−0.16

0.877

  

39.87

[0.00, 77.78]

  

0.054

 
 

LIB

Drug On

31

24

−1.40

 

5.82

5.99e-09

  

0.00

[0.00, 0.00]

  

0.999

 
 

SN

Total

96

91

−0.29

 

−0.62

0.537

43.30

3.21e-08

88.45

[77.41, 94.10]

−0.54

0.590

0.505

 
 

SN

Drug Off

65

67

0.33

 

0.96

0.335

  

71.02

[17.27, 89.85]

  

0.469

 
 

SN

Drug On

31

24

−1.51

 

5.65

1.62e-08

  

0.00

[0.00, 0.00]

  

1

 
 

TMC

Total

118

126

−0.43

 

−1.83

0.067

26.24

9.54e-04

69.52

[39.19, 84.72]

0.07

0.941

0.917

 
 

TMC

Drug Off

87

102

−0.16

 

1.09

0.274

  

1.14

[0.00, 71.14]

  

0.193

 
 

TMC

Drug On

31

24

−1.50

 

−3.29

0.001

  

63.08

[0.00, 91.52]

  

1

 
 

PFC

Total

54

59

0.07

 

0.27

0.784

6.20

0.102

51.59

[0.00, 83.00]

0.01

0.988

0.066

 

DSC

 
 

STR

Total

214

245

0.21

 

−1.30

0.193

70.47

1.79e-08

75.88

[61.98, 84.69]

1.01

0.311

0.610

 
 

STR

Drug Off

93

120

0.38

 

2.31

0.021

  

46.30

[34.08, 89.39]

  

0.782

 
 

STR

Drug native

45

53

0.74

 

4.32

1.58e-05

  

0

[0.00, 84.69]

  

0.951

 
 

STR

Drug On

121

125

0.06

 

0.20

0.839

  

83.76

[34.08, 89.39]

  

0.076

 
 

LIB

Total

57

71

<−0.01

 

−0.002

0.989

5.03

0.284

20.51

[0.00, 66.17]

−0.33

0.737

0.050

 
 

LIB

Drug Off

47

58

0.01

 

0.05

0.962

  

39.50

[34.08, 89.39]

  

0.050

 
 

PFC

Total

49

56

−0.23

 

−0.74

0.458

7.88

0.048

61.95

[0.00, 87.23]

  

0.214

 
 

TMC

Total

49

56

<−0.01

 

−0.03

0.976

1.61

0.657

0.00

[0.00, 84.69]

  

0.050

 

D1

 
 

LIB

Total

66

92

−0.41

 

−1.41

0.158

16.70

5.11e-03

70.06

[29.91, 87.21]

−3.63

3.00e-04

0.714

 
 

LIB

Drug Off

60

80

−0.20

 

−0.82

0.413

  

55.30

[0.00, 83.49]

  

0.214

 
 

PFC

Total

91

140

−0.46

 

−1.10

0.269

60.12

1.43e-10

88.36

[79.35, 93.43]

−3.13

0.0017

0.925

 
 

PFC

Drug Off

85

128

−0.14

 

−0.45

0.646

  

82.33

[64.78, 91.14]

  

0.169

 
 

STR

Total

103

140

−0.30

 

−1.17

0.243

25.59

5.96e-04

72.64

[44.02, 86.63]

−3.46

5.00e-04

0.634

 
 

STR

Drug Off

85

128

−0.05

 

−0.33

0.741

  

20.91

[0.00, 64.27]

  

0.065

 
 

TMC

Total

66

92

−0.64

 

1.38

0.167

35.71

6.83e-07

86.31

[72.53, 93.25]

−3.16

0.002

0.976

 
 

TMC

Drug Off

60

80

−0.26

 

−0.79

0.427

  

73.55

[34.08, 89.39]

  

0.327

 

DAT

 
 

STR

Total

46

59

0.34

 

0.58

0.564

28.57

2.75e-06

89.50

[75.92, 95.42]

  

0.402

 
  1. DAT dopamine transporter, DSC dopamine synthesis capacity, LIB limbic cortex, PFC prefrontal cortex, SN Substantia nigra, STR striatum, THA thalamus, TMC temporal cortex. BOLD represent statistical significance.