Table 1 A list of previously published large collections of thermal tolerance data considered for harmonization in this study, with information on when it was found and the reason for inclusion or exclusion.
From: Global thermal tolerance compilation for freshwater invertebrates and fish
Collection | Found | Include | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
Bennett et al.47 (GlobTherm) | Conceptualization | yes | Most species in a single collection to date, includes freshwater taxa |
Leiva et al.52 | Conceptualization | yes | Large collection including freshwater taxa |
Lutterschmidt & Hutchinson29 | Scoping searches | no | Age, duplicated in later collections |
Beitinger et al.18 | Scoping searches | no | Age, included in GlobTherm |
Bates et al.90 | Scoping searches | no | Age, duplication with other collections, common authors with later collections (Morley, Bates, Sunday) |
Chown et al.91 | Scoping searches | no | Age, duplication with other collections |
Rohr et al.88 | Scoping searches | no | Focus on amphibians |
Sasaki & Dam89 | Scoping searches | no | Only copepods, only freshwater source is duplicate |
Cereja53 | Scoping searches | yes | Aquatic ectotherms, including freshwater taxa |
Sundermann et al.77 | Scoping searches | yes | Freshwater invertebrates |
Gunderson & Stillmann85 | References | no | Age |
Comte & Olden84 | References | no | Entirely duplicated in Dahlke et al.81 |
Morley et al.51 | References | yes | Large collection of thermal tolerance including freshwater taxa |
Hasnain et al.78 | After first search | no | Age, duplication with other collections |
Pinsky et al.86 | After first search | no | No freshwater taxa |
Barbarossa et al.87 | After first search | no | Source compilations already included |
Welch & Jager79 | After first search | no | Meta-compilation, all source compilations either irrelevant or already included |
Bonacina et al.80 | After first search | no | Lack of relevant metrics |
Dahlke et al.81 | After first search | yes | Additional papers for freshwater fish |
Pottier et al.82 | After first search | yes | Recent collection including freshwater taxa |
Sasaki et al.83 | After first search | yes | Recent collection including freshwater taxa |
