Table 9 Statistical analysis based on Wilcoxon test between AD-COA-L and its rivals using CEC2017, D = 50.
F | AOA | COA | GBO | SMA | PSO | INFO | SCA | HHO | SWO | WOA | WSO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
C17-G1 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G3 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 9.271025LEL-03 | 6.319757LEL-05 | 1.254382LEL-01 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.483928LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 9.777219LEL-02 |
C17-G4 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 6.835856LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G5 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.382036LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G6 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G7 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 4.285686LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 6.339136LEL-06 | 1.254382LEL-01 | 2.613431LEL-04 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 8.944301LEL-04 |
C17-G8 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.920921LEL-06 | 1.126540LEL-05 | 2.353421LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.964581LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.197338LEL-03 |
C17-G9 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 3.882182LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.972948LEL-05 | 2.126636LEL-06 | 2.584559LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.126636LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.369362LEL-01 |
C17-G10 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.493564LEL-05 | 1.286631LEL-03 | 2.596713LEL-05 | 3.609433LEL-03 | 8.466082LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 7.730944LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 8.187753LEL-05 | 8.466082LEL-06 |
C17-G11 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.890972LEL-04 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.238080LEL-05 | 3.872303LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 3.181679LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 8.466082LEL-06 |
C17-G12 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 4.285686LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 5.304401LEL-01 |
C17-G13 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 5.709650LEL-02 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G14 | 2.603328LEL-06 | 4.729202LEL-06 | 3.181679LEL-06 | 4.729202LEL-06 | 4.729202LEL-06 | 7.970983LEL-01 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 4.491890LEL-02 |
C17-G15 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.126636LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 3.064999LEL-04 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 3.405257LEL-05 |
C17-G16 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.848596LEL-02 | 5.306992LEL-05 | 1.319417LEL-02 | 5.751653LEL-06 | 1.890972LEL-04 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 4.285686LEL-06 | 1.920921LEL-06 | 8.466082LEL-06 |
C17-G17 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.920921LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.920921LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G18 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.603328LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.126636LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G19 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.603328LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 6.583305LEL-04 | 1.742281LEL-04 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G20 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.414704LEL-03 | 5.792446LEL-05 | 3.854236LEL-03 | 3.600388LEL-01 | 6.268281LEL-02 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.779074LEL-01 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.843424LEL-05 |
C17-G21 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 3.112315LEL-05 | 1.238080LEL-05 | 2.224827LEL-04 | 1.149922LEL-04 | 2.105260LEL-03 | 2.126636LEL-06 | 4.071512LEL-05 | 2.126636LEL-06 | 3.181679LEL-06 | 1.798848LEL-05 |
C17-G22 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.920921LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 8.220647LEL-02 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G23 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 7.513662LEL-05 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.613431LEL-04 | 8.466082LEL-06 | 2.957462LEL-03 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 7.513662LEL-05 |
C17-G24 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G25 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.613431LEL-04 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G26 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 6.319757LEL-05 | 1.846219LEL-01 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G27 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 4.071512LEL-05 | 6.983783LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 7.521331LEL-02 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G28 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.024633LEL-05 | 3.493456LEL-01 | 1.020107LEL-01 | 1.493564LEL-05 | 6.339136LEL-06 | 1.126540LEL-05 | 6.564114LEL-02 | 5.216493LEL-06 | 2.603328LEL-06 | 2.411796LEL-04 |
C17-G29 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 2.596713LEL-05 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.986102LEL-01 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
C17-G30 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 3.181679LEL-06 | 3.181679LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 7.655193LEL-01 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 | 1.734398LEL-06 |
