Table 3 Sensitivity analysis of parameter p

From: Adaptive dynamic crayfish algorithm with multi-enhanced strategy for global high-dimensional optimization and real-engineering problems

F

 

p=0.1

p=0.2

p=0.3

p=0.4

p=0.5

p=0.6

p=0.7

p=0.8

p=0.9

F1

AVG

2914.970

2790.631

2370.477

2016.222

3080.839

2745.107

2984.092

1955.950

1785.844

STD

3067.888

2621.845

2365.965

2739.999

3037.802

2842.528

2638.295

1801.859

1842.695

F3

AVG

300.000

300.000

300.000

300.000

300.000

300.000

300.000

300.000

300.000

STD

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

F4

AVG

404.996

402.433

402.154

402.114

404.574

402.061

404.482

402.152

404.481

STD

12.157

0.828

1.080

0.970

12.028

1.074

12.750

0.799

11.754

F5

AVG

514.725

515.678

512.674

511.543

514.213

515.160

512.533

510.604

511.504

STD

6.816

6.507

4.764

5.751

6.352

6.554

7.207

5.459

5.650

F6

AVG

600.005

600.007

600.007

600.001

600.007

600.026

600.004

600.066

600.074

STD

0.022

0.029

0.029

0.002

0.019

0.119

0.011

0.260

0.389

F7

AVG

732.884

730.476

729.012

727.287

728.611

727.268

728.482

729.400

727.354

STD

12.888

9.431

8.066

8.166

6.564

8.052

9.762

8.336

8.656

F8

AVG

820.297

818.175

816.649

816.483

815.787

818.308

816.417

820.562

813.797

STD

5.210

5.616

5.969

5.535

6.313

4.941

6.747

9.487

6.951

F9

AVG

900.570

900.091

900.488

900.261

900.231

900.258

900.148

900.106

900.284

STD

2.781

0.346

1.202

0.728

0.589

0.710

0.515

0.371

1.091

F10

AVG

1796.412

1720.963

1773.530

1783.348

1822.633

1840.329

1868.146

1855.204

1825.656

STD

324.757

278.732

281.498

280.044

297.047

235.682

204.305

295.473

244.190

F11

AVG

1114.407

1110.341

1111.510

1109.740

1108.841

1111.268

1111.852

1109.778

1112.042

STD

10.635

7.742

11.686

5.510

6.599

10.989

6.577

5.377

7.786

F12

AVG

1.109E + 04

1.243E + 04

1.099E + 04

1.294E + 04

1.448E + 04

1.193E + 04

1.359E + 04

1.188E + 04

2.482E + 04

STD

7.557E + 03

9.866E + 03

9.934E + 03

1.045E + 04

1.080E + 04

8.517E + 03

1.152E + 04

9.139E + 03

4.752E + 04

F13

AVG

7319.643

9452.287

7555.361

7322.329

7960.247

6937.152

7433.426

6853.058

7646.979

STD

5166.980

5813.553

4917.643

5548.804

4399.696

4333.280

4867.852

5112.088

4662.249

F14

AVG

1456.690

1463.982

1456.455

1464.498

1466.125

1455.323

1467.344

1466.175

1511.596

STD

23.494

38.935

23.761

35.069

31.725

33.837

28.646

44.535

164.483

F15

AVG

1539.660

1581.334

1580.945

1661.276

1587.780

1596.697

1611.015

1583.903

1671.012

STD

32.877

88.755

67.285

183.605

80.153

77.588

121.319

103.876

389.450

F16

AVG

1715.579

1722.061

1692.191

1679.430

1698.432

1688.219

1668.952

1698.046

1666.663

STD

117.040

107.498

109.071

83.413

103.975

120.341

95.413

118.366

83.824

F17

AVG

1737.922

1736.327

1735.392

1738.064

1737.101

1741.193

1743.505

1747.238

1740.305

STD

20.574

18.010

19.442

21.392

15.741

18.604

19.466

28.317

15.090

F18

AVG

1.029E + 04

9.393E + 03

1.211E + 04

1.059E + 04

1.019E + 04

1.221E + 04

9.135E + 03

1.169E + 04

9.884E + 03

STD

9.197E + 03

7.682E + 03

1.051E + 04

8.706E + 03

7.206E + 03

1.233E + 04

8.077E + 03

9.703E + 03

9.452E + 03

F19

AVG

4635.888

5114.007

4388.294

5825.227

4620.957

3934.643

5413.622

5432.556

3798.480

STD

2913.909

3773.489

3528.607

5801.014

4399.353

2540.750

3678.078

4216.590

2759.922

F20

AVG

2058.041

2060.533

2058.633

2059.613

2068.792

2064.003

2064.347

2056.833

2068.118

STD

53.794

53.131

55.057

60.764

60.269

54.967

75.268

61.240

48.689

F21

AVG

2274.929

2263.345

2263.778

2228.304

2227.895

2231.466

2250.757

2256.763

2220.703

STD

57.802

58.590

58.888

47.797

48.363

49.932

56.655

59.820

41.094

F22

AVG

2301.898

2298.926

2296.440

2296.126

2295.419

2301.779

2295.712

2295.696

2301.204

STD

0.904

13.129

19.487

20.576

24.472

1.035

21.865

23.053

0.558

F23

AVG

2614.667

2617.113

2615.311

2615.403

2616.685

2616.896

2615.965

2616.408

2618.894

STD

5.862

10.113

6.157

7.735

7.847

7.181

5.746

6.039

9.044

F24

AVG

2748.502

2738.693

2739.975

2738.123

2750.403

2749.353

2721.769

2722.450

2739.040

STD

8.604

45.496

45.839

45.649

8.502

7.064

75.416

75.860

45.711

F25

AVG

2929.767

2926.761

2927.735

2932.863

2928.393

2926.720

2934.886

2926.951

2931.257

STD

29.382

23.555

22.509

20.706

22.824

23.114

23.166

23.681

21.769

F26

AVG

2918.634

2896.783

2962.660

2955.677

2903.703

2907.698

2967.895

2898.328

2898.653

STD

206.513

79.111

207.953

241.552

53.876

52.042

273.238

48.618

78.304

F27

AVG

3097.828

3098.844

3099.497

3092.709

3092.203

3093.596

3091.954

3095.301

3092.807

STD

17.995

22.933

17.283

2.631

2.322

10.989

2.632

16.475

3.088

F28

AVG

3330.768

3359.143

3368.113

3318.037

3349.360

3380.123

3355.468

3350.177

3362.445

STD

153.060

160.850

153.606

159.558

118.861

118.293

143.109

186.773

181.344

F29

AVG

3208.716

3199.846

3210.029

3219.014

3208.830

3198.291

3198.231

3198.817

3200.998

STD

33.125

45.961

63.445

59.219

48.905

45.834

53.011

46.787

42.707

F30

AVG

1.681E + 05

2.379E + 05

1.053E + 05

4.641E + 05

3.048E + 05

5.831E + 05

3.527E + 05

4.640E + 05

2.400E + 05

STD

3.072E + 05

4.152E + 05

2.088E + 05

9.019E + 05

5.297E + 05

9.073E + 05

4.265E + 05

6.565E + 05

2.638E + 05

FR rank

5.41

5.11

4.93

4.48

5.01

4.89

5.08

4.87

5.22

Back to article page