Table 6 Comparison of results on F1 to F13 with 100D.
From: Bi-objective jellyfish algorithm for team formation problem
Fn | GA | PSO | GWO | HBO | AO | POA | JSO | CJSO | CJSESOS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
F1 | 5.7×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 6×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) | 4.4×\(\:{10}^{-7}\) 1.5×\(\:{10}^{-6}\) | 6.4×\(\:{10}^{-70}\) 2.9×\(\:{10}^{-69}\) | 1.6×\(\:{10}^{-17}\) 4.8×\(\:{10}^{-17}\) | 6.34×\(\:{10}^{-32}\) 2.3×\(\:{10}^{-30}\) | 4.95×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) 2.13×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) | 1.087 4.6×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 1.176×\(\:{10}^{-27}\) 3.642×\(\:{10}^{-27}\) | 6.8×\(\:{10}^{-50}\) 0 |
F2 | 5.4×\(\:{10}^{+10}\) 1.9×\(\:{10}^{+11}\) | 1.9×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) 5.6×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 4.7×\(\:{10}^{-41}\) 4.6×\(\:{10}^{-41}\) | 6.3×\(\:{10}^{-13}\) 1.8×\(\:{10}^{-12}\) | 3.1 ×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) 1.6×\(\:{10}^{-13}\) | 2.04×\(\:{10}^{-8}\) 7.26×\(\:{10}^{-8}\) | 4.4×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 1.1×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 4.382×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) 5.86×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) | 5×\(\:{10}^{-30}\) 8.7×\(\:{10}^{-30}\) |
F3 | 6.8×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) 1.4×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) | 1.1 2.4 | 6.1×\(\:{10}^{-19}\) 2.7×\(\:{10}^{-18}\) | 1.2×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 6.2×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) | 1.5×\(\:{10}^{-26}\) 6.6×\(\:{10}^{-26}\) | 5.51×\(\:{10}^{-13}\) 2.37×\(\:{10}^{-12}\) | 8.3×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) 3.1×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) | 2.596×\(\:{10}^{-21}\) 1.3×\(\:{10}^{-20}\) | 1×\(\:{10}^{-29}\) 9.5×\(\:{10}^{-28}\) |
F4 | 8 ×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 4.309 | 3.9 1.07 | 2.7×\(\:{10}^{-17}\) 5.2×\(\:{10}^{-17}\) | 5.3 2.77 | 1.3×\(\:{10}^{-16}\) 5. 9×\(\:{10}^{-16}\) | 3.11×\(\:{10}^{-9}\) 6.99×\(\:{10}^{-9}\) | 1.31 3.4×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 1.3×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) 1.7×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) | 1×\(\:{10}^{-32}\) 5.5×\(\:{10}^{-30}\) |
F5 | 1.6×\(\:{10}^{+8}\) 4.5×\(\:{10}^{+7}\) | 3.3×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) 1.6×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) | 2.6×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 6.4×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 6.9×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 4.1×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 3.4×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 5.9×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 9.3×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 7.63×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 5.1×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 1×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 4.6×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 8.8×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 9.8×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 3.8×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) |
F6 | 7×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 5.4×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 2×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 7×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 5.2×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) 3.4×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 1.7×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 5.9×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 3.5×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) 2.7×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 5.2×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) 2.8×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 1.1×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 4.8×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 2.81×\(\:{10}^{-5}\) 2.93×\(\:{10}^{-5}\) | 4.03×\(\:{10}^{-6}\) 4.15×\(\:{10}^{-6}\) |
F7 | −3×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) 6.9×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) | −9×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 7.6×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) | −6E×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 5.4×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) | −1×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 2×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) | −1×\(\:{10}^{+5}\) 6×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) | −1.38×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 1.13×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) | −4×\(\:{10}^{+4}\) 4×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) | −1.25×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) 1.95×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) | −1.25×\(\:{10}^{+3}\) 1.95×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) |
F8 | 3.7×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) 3.1×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 4.8×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 1.8×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 3.9×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) 1.4×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) | 5.62 1.96 | 0 0 | 3.9×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) 2.1×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) | 1.1×\(\:{10}^{+2}\) 2.8×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 0 0 | 0 0 |
F9 | 2×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 2.3×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 6×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 3×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 1.3×\(\:{10}^{-14}\) 9.2×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) | 4.1×\(\:{10}^{-10}\) 4.4×\(\:{10}^{-10}\) | 8.8×\(\:{10}^{-16}\) 0 | 4.6×\(\:{10}^{-9}\) 1.1×\(\:{10}^{-8}\) | 4.8×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 1.6×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 8.73×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) 3.2×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) | 1.9×\(\:{10}^{-19}\) 5.4×\(\:{10}^{-18}\) |
F10 | 4.7×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) 7.6×\(\:{10}^{+1}\) | 1×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 1.1×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) | 1.3×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) 3.7×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 4.2×\(\:{10}^{-12}\) 2.3×\(\:{10}^{-11}\) | 0 0 | 1.7×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) 8.8×\(\:{10}^{-15}\) | 7.6×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 1.4×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 0 0 | 0 0 |
F11 | 3.3×\(\:{10}^{+8}\) 8.7×\(\:{10}^{+7}\) | 2.5×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 8.1×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) | 2.5×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 8.8×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 5.9×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 3.5×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 2.8×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) 4.9×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 8.3×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 8×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) | 6.6×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) 2.9×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) | 4.6×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) 2.17×\(\:{10}^{-2}\) | 7.2×\(\:{10}^{-5}\) 3.3×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) |
F12 | 7.1×\(\:{10}^{+8}\) 1×\(\:{10}^{+8}\) | 3×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) 4.9×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 3.2×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 1.9×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 3.6×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 3.5×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 3.4×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) 5.1×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 9.9 4.1×\(\:{10}^{-3}\) | 3.8×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) 1.4×\(\:{10}^{-1}\) | 5.4×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) 6.95×\(\:{10}^{-4}\) | 1.2×\(\:{10}^{-22}\) 1.7×\(\:{10}^{-22}\) |
