Table 7 The Wilcoxon signed rank test results between CDAOA and other intelligent algorithms.
Functions | CDAOA vs. EVO | CDAOA vs. SWO | CDAOA vs. KOA | CDAOA vs. GRO | CDAOA vs. GOOSE | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
R+ | R- | P-VALUE | S | R+ | R- | P-VALUE | S | R+ | R- | P-VALUE | S | R+ | R- | P-VALUE | S | R+ | R- | P-VALUE | S | |
1 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
2 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
3 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
4 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
5 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
6 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
7 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
8 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
9 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
10 | 459 | 6 | 4.20E-10 | + | 464 | 1 | 7.39E-11 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
11 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 0 | 0 | 1.00E+00 | = | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 0 | 0 | 1.00E+00 | = | 414 | 51 | 1.93E-10 | + |
12 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 0 | 0 | 1.00E+00 | = | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
13 | 387 | 78 | 1.44E-04 | + | 0 | 0 | 1.00E+00 | = | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 0 | 0 | 1.00E+00 | = | 416 | 49 | 1.92E-10 | + |
14 | 442 | 23 | 1.53E-05 | + | 463 | 2 | 2.61E-10 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + |
15 | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 435 | 30 | 4.57E-12 | + |
16 | 378 | 87 | 1.27E-02 | + | 465 | 0 | 1.21E-12 | + | 418 | 47 | 8.66E-05 | + | 418 | 47 | 8.66E-05 | + | 406 | 59 | 3.01E-11 | + |
\(+ / = / -\) | 16/0/0 | 13/3/0 | 16/0/0 | 14/2/0 | 16/0/0 | |||||||||||||||
