Table 7 Comparison of current study with related study.

From: Ergonomic assessment of a multi-joint actuated lower extremity exoskeleton to assist dynamic lifting and carrying tasks

Exoskeleton/device

Activity

Ref.

Rectus femoris

Vastus medialis

Gastrocnemius

Remark

Exo for current study16

Load lifting and carrying

 

30–38% decrease

30–60% decrease

40–58% decrease

Exoskeleton is actuated at the hip and knee decreased activities of muscle group. Assistance is provided to assist both hip and knee flexion/extention

PLAD (personal lift assistive device)

Squat and free style lifting

42

Squat: 29–47% increase and free style lifting: 38–83% increase

  

Exoskeleton used elastic elements to reduced the lumbar moment during lifting and bending tasks but increased activities of Rectus Femoris

Passive lower-limb exoskeleton (Chairless Chair)

Sitting

43

  

25% decrease

No actuation

Passive Exoskeleton

Lifting (squat, stoop, orientation)

44

  

21% increase

No actuation. Exoskeleton uses semi-rigid bar and springs to support trunk and hip extension

Under Actuated Exo

Walking and load carrying

41

11–49% decrease

 

11–49% decrease

Actuation at the knee to assist knee flexion/extension

ALEX II (One leg powered hip exo)

Gait adapted walking pattern

Load-free walking exercise

Lenzi, et al.22

22.3%

 

45.0%

Actuation at the hip to assist walking

MINDWALKER powered hip and knee joint

Load-free walking exercise

Sylos-Labini, et al.23

0%

0%

0%

Influenced by usability, flexibility and comfort.

Hyundai H-WEX waist/hip-assisted for low back assistance

Lifting task (loads of 10 kg)

LEE26

~ 0%

~ 0%

~ 0%

Actuation at the hip to assist hip-extensor/knee-flexor muscle group