Table 3 Interval-valued spherical fuzzy aggregated decision matrix.

From: Evaluating generative AI tools for visual communication design using the CoCoSo method under interval valued spherical fuzzy environment

 

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{1}\)

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{2}\)

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{3}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{1}\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.71\)

\(\:0.74\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.19\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.85\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.14\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{2}\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.52\)

\(\:0.70\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.49\)

\(\:0.76\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.87\)

\(\:0.88\)

\(\:0.16\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{3}\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.71\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.19\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.84\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.14\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{4}\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.71\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.48\)

\(\:0.76\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.85\)

\(\:0.87\)

\(\:0.15\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{5}\)

\(\:0.33\)

\(\:0.45\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.75\)

\(\:0.22\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.47\)

\(\:0.77\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.23\)

\(\:0.89\)

\(\:0.90\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.22\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{6}\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.43\)

\(\:0.74\)

\(\:0.76\)

\(\:0.23\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.34\)

\(\:0.46\)

\(\:0.77\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.85\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.14\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{7}\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.47\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.75\)

\(\:0.23\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.20\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.84\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.14\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{8}\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.76\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.19\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.34\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.87\)

\(\:0.15\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{9}\)

\(\:0.22\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.34\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.41\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.19\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.34\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.87\)

\(\:0.15\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{10}\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.47\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.75\)

\(\:0.23\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.87\)

\(\:0.88\)

\(\:0.16\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:\varvec{m}\varvec{a}\varvec{x}\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.52\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.34\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.49\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.89\)

\(\:0.90\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.22\)

\(\:\varvec{m}\varvec{i}\varvec{n}\)

\(\:0.22\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.70\)

\(\:0.73\)

\(\:0.21\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.76\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.17\)

\(\:0.23\)

\(\:0.84\)

\(\:0.86\)

\(\:0.14\)

\(\:0.21\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{4}\)

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{5}\)

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{6}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{1}\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.47\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.83\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{2}\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.62\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.41\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.33\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.40\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{3}\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.68\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.33\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.70\)

\(\:0.40\)

\(\:0.43\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.83\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{4}\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.71\)

\(\:0.48\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.72\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.46\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.16\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{5}\)

\(\:0.49\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.40\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.83\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{6}\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.71\)

\(\:0.48\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.61\)

\(\:0.77\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.41\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.33\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.43\)

\(\:0.79\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.16\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{7}\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.68\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.33\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.74\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.83\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{8}\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.72\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.40\)

\(\:0.81\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{9}\)

\(\:0.45\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.54\)

\(\:0.57\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.70\)

\(\:0.40\)

\(\:0.43\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.31\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.83\)

\(\:0.18\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{10}\)

\(\:0.45\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.54\)

\(\:0.57\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.74\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.29\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.38\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.84\)

\(\:0.19\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:\varvec{m}\varvec{a}\varvec{x}\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.71\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.30\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.47\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.37\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.46\)

\(\:0.82\)

\(\:0.84\)

\(\:0.19\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:\varvec{m}\varvec{i}\varvec{n}\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.48\)

\(\:0.53\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.56\)

\(\:0.35\)

\(\:0.40\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.32\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.36\)

\(\:0.78\)

\(\:0.80\)

\(\:0.16\)

\(\:0.24\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{C}}_{7}\)

 

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{m}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathfrak{n}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{l}}\)

\(\:{\mathcal{a}}^{\varvec{u}}\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{1}\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.52\)

\(\:0.61\)

\(\:0.63\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.35\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{2}\)

\(\:0.46\)

\(\:0.60\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.61\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.33\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{3}\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{4}\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{5}\)

\(\:0.43\)

\(\:0.57\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.62\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.34\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{6}\)

\(\:0.46\)

\(\:0.60\)

\(\:0.57\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.25\)

\(\:0.32\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{7}\)

\(\:0.44\)

\(\:0.57\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.61\)

\(\:0.26\)

\(\:0.33\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{8}\)

\(\:0.42\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.59\)

\(\:0.62\)

\(\:0.27\)

\(\:0.34\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{9}\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)

 

\(\:{\varvec{A}}_{10}\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.52\)

\(\:0.61\)

\(\:0.63\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.35\)

 

\(\:\varvec{m}\varvec{a}\varvec{x}\)

\(\:0.50\)

\(\:0.64\)

\(\:0.61\)

\(\:0.63\)

\(\:0.28\)

\(\:0.35\)

 

\(\:\varvec{m}\varvec{i}\varvec{n}\)

\(\:0.39\)

\(\:0.52\)

\(\:0.55\)

\(\:0.58\)

\(\:0.24\)

\(\:0.32\)