Table 3 Ranges and optimal parameters of standard PID controller.
Parameter | Range | mNRBO | NRBO | HO | GEO | SMA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\({K}_{P}\) | [1–10] | 6.6595 | 8.0709 | 7.2614 | 5.8035 | 7.0093 |
\({T}_{I}\) | [20–200] | 138.6948 | 181.1913 | 166.1372 | 137.1584 | 161.8158 |
\({T}_{D}\) | [10–100] | 27.7611 | 49.4473 | 52.4883 | 55.1365 | 52.3058 |
\(\alpha\) | [0.05–0.2] | 0.0780 | 0.0756 | 0.0825 | 0.1052 | 0.0715 |