Table 19 Exemplar simulation for Structure 1 in Fig. 1a: Sensitivity of secret key by UACI.
From: Novel structures of chaos-based parallel multiple image encryption and FPGA implementation
Sensitivity on \(\gamma ^{(2)}_0\) | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\(N_e\) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||||||||||
Channel | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B |
Baboon | 33.378 | 33.502 | 33.427 | 33.487 | 33.428 | 33.368 | 33.427 | 33.487 | 33.476 | 33.395 | 33.451 | 33.473 | 33.454 | 33.498 | 33.452 |
Flowers | 33.514 | 33.456 | 33.465 | 33.461 | 33.462 | 33.519 | 33.469 | 33.518 | 33.406 | 33.461 | 33.552 | 33.519 | 33.383 | 33.424 | 33.529 |
Peppers | 33.440 | 33.455 | 33.478 | 33.506 | 33.540 | 33.499 | 33.410 | 33.454 | 33.351 | 33.450 | 33.421 | 33.432 | 33.444 | 33.421 | 33.500 |
Goldhill | 33.449 | 33.475 | 33.422 | 33.460 | 33.439 | 33.473 | 33.437 | 33.512 | 33.468 | 33.420 | 33.435 | 33.452 | 33.499 | 33.440 | 33.470 |
Black | 33.492 | 33.457 | 33.446 | 33.532 | 33.511 | ||||||||||
Boats | 33.443 | 33.485 | 33.510 | 33.480 | 33.460 | ||||||||||
Clock | 33.580 | 33.568 | 33.447 | 33.474 | 33.360 | ||||||||||
White | 33.490 | 33.401 | 33.525 | 33.505 | 33.468 | ||||||||||
Average | 33.467 (Pass) | 33.472 (Pass) | 33.459 (Pass) | 33.466 (Pass) | 33.457 (Pass) | ||||||||||
Sensitivity on \(\gamma ^{(1)}_0\) | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\(N_e\) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||||||||||
Channel | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B |
Baboon | 33.485 | 33.417 | 33.565 | 33.533 | 33.441 | 33.486 | 33.526 | 33.505 | 33.466 | 33.395 | 33.477 | 33.537 | 33.466 | 33.353 | 33.495 |
Flowers | 33.419 | 33.503 | 33.422 | 33.531 | 33.471 | 33.470 | 33.458 | 33.539 | 33.435 | 33.474 | 33.491 | 33.509 | 33.428 | 33.606 | 33.337 |
Peppers | 33.467 | 33.354 | 33.532 | 33.431 | 33.513 | 33.420 | 33.415 | 33.499 | 33.459 | 33.464 | 33.529 | 33.489 | 33.541 | 33.430 | 33.424 |
Goldhill | 33.492 | 33.448 | 33.422 | 33.467 | 33.507 | 33.532 | 33.495 | 33.448 | 33.453 | 33.459 | 33.436 | 33.466 | 33.450 | 33.487 | 33.424 |
Black | 33.493 | 33.477 | 33.463 | 33.451 | 33.441 | ||||||||||
Boats | 33.490 | 33.494 | 33.483 | 33.489 | 33.465 | ||||||||||
Clock | 33.643 | 33.481 | 33.398 | 33.564 | 33.425 | ||||||||||
White | 33.476 | 33.454 | 33.438 | 33.446 | 33.469 | ||||||||||
Average | 33.477 (Pass) | 33.482 (Pass) | 33.468 (Pass) | 33.480 (Pass) | 33.453 (Pass) | ||||||||||
Sensitivity on \(x^{(2)}_0\) | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\(N_e\) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||||||||||
Channel | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B |
Baboon | 33.443 | 33.405 | 33.436 | 33.426 | 33.391 | 33.423 | 33.515 | 33.496 | 33.520 | 33.519 | 33.483 | 33.371 | 33.411 | 33.475 | 33.512 |
Flowers | 33.462 | 33.555 | 33.549 | 33.460 | 33.421 | 33.405 | 33.503 | 33.488 | 33.467 | 33.445 | 33.475 | 33.531 | 33.476 | 33.531 | 33.429 |
Peppers | 33.495 | 33.531 | 33.488 | 33.387 | 33.549 | 33.455 | 33.448 | 33.511 | 33.520 | 33.459 | 33.470 | 33.467 | 33.433 | 33.424 | 33.445 |
Goldhill | 33.469 | 33.463 | 33.445 | 33.453 | 33.448 | 33.392 | 33.497 | 33.512 | 33.444 | 33.489 | 33.504 | 33.450 | 33.420 | 33.437 | 33.449 |
Black | 33.461 | 33.492 | 33.464 | 33.489 | 33.465 | ||||||||||
Boats | 33.458 | 33.396 | 33.449 | 33.472 | 33.465 | ||||||||||
Clock | 33.515 | 33.541 | 33.386 | 33.385 | 33.519 | ||||||||||
White | 33.484 | 33.485 | 33.468 | 33.449 | 33.449 | ||||||||||
Average | 33.479 (Pass) | 33.445 (Pass) | 33.481 (Pass) | 33.466 (Pass) | 33.459 (Pass) | ||||||||||
Sensitivity on \(x^{(1)}_0\) | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\(N_e\) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||||||||||
Channel | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B |
Baboon | 33.520 | 33.447 | 33.503 | 33.472 | 33.469 | 33.395 | 33.428 | 33.500 | 33.526 | 33.484 | 33.541 | 33.491 | 33.430 | 33.395 | 33.450 |
Flowers | 33.429 | 33.483 | 33.398 | 33.396 | 33.450 | 33.453 | 33.456 | 33.415 | 33.544 | 33.583 | 33.418 | 33.517 | 33.411 | 33.405 | 33.288 |
Peppers | 33.469 | 33.499 | 33.440 | 33.459 | 33.438 | 33.487 | 33.518 | 33.379 | 33.500 | 33.400 | 33.529 | 33.449 | 33.488 | 33.411 | 33.445 |
Goldhill | 33.517 | 33.447 | 33.444 | 33.455 | 33.476 | 33.489 | 33.423 | 33.452 | 33.406 | 33.420 | 33.476 | 33.451 | 33.414 | 33.461 | 33.440 |
Black | 33.516 | 33.490 | 33.441 | 33.485 | 33.532 | ||||||||||
Boats | 33.454 | 33.390 | 33.505 | 33.530 | 33.457 | ||||||||||
Clock | 33.532 | 33.471 | 33.494 | 33.548 | 33.258 | ||||||||||
White | 33.496 | 33.492 | 33.416 | 33.451 | 33.532 | ||||||||||
Average | 33.475 (Pass) | 33.455 (Pass) | 33.463 (Pass) | 33.486 (Pass) | 33.426 (Pass) | ||||||||||
Sensitivity on \(S_0\) | |||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
\(N_e\) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ||||||||||
Channel | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B | R | G | B |
Baboon | 33.466 | 33.523 | 33.434 | 33.520 | 33.432 | 33.502 | 33.528 | 33.487 | 33.525 | 33.458 | 33.445 | 33.446 | 33.498 | 33.473 | 33.435 |
Flowers | 33.450 | 33.456 | 33.519 | 33.409 | 33.457 | 33.484 | 33.462 | 33.487 | 33.525 | 33.478 | 33.388 | 33.551 | 33.441 | 33.579 | 33.440 |
Peppers | 33.489 | 33.470 | 33.366 | 33.439 | 33.433 | 33.412 | 33.435 | 33.420 | 33.449 | 33.513 | 33.499 | 33.417 | 33.458 | 33.537 | 33.540 |
Goldhill | 33.527 | 33.423 | 33.525 | 33.469 | 33.419 | 33.474 | 33.501 | 33.483 | 33.474 | 33.422 | 33.478 | 33.442 | 33.478 | 33.453 | 33.512 |
Black | 33.426 | 33.551 | 33.431 | 33.446 | 33.526 | ||||||||||
Boats | 33.497 | 33.449 | 33.436 | 33.465 | 33.446 | ||||||||||
Clock | 33.501 | 33.633 | 33.383 | 33.573 | 33.471 | ||||||||||
White | 33.494 | 33.492 | 33.518 | 33.496 | 33.521 | ||||||||||
Average | 33.447 (Pass) | 33.448 (Pass) | 33.483 (Pass) | 33.466 (Pass) | 33.460 (Pass) | ||||||||||