Table 10 Friedman test analysis on CEC2019 test suite.

From: Adaptive memory-based opposition and midpoint mutation in black winged kite algorithm for global optimization and engineering applications

Functions

PSO

GWO

GJO

SO

SCSO

AVOA

CMAES

SHADE

BKA

CBKA

IBKA

QOBLBKA

AMOMM-BKA

Fun24

13

10

8

9

5

6

11

12

4

1

2

7

3

Fun25

7

3

4

1

3

1

6

1

2

2

1

5

1

Fun26

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

Fun27

3

4

12

2

8

7

13

1

11

6

9

10

5

Fun28

3

8

11

2

6

7

4

1

10

9

13

12

5

Fun29

8

12

10

11

3

2

13

4

7

6

5

9

1

Fun30

7

11

12

3

9

10

13

2

8

6

5

4

1

Fun31

10

5

11

8

9

13

12

4

7

2

3

6

1

Fun32

3

9

13

1

10

7

2

4

12

8

11

6

5

Fun33

9

3

6

10

8

5

11

7

4

2

6

9

1

Average rank

6.40

6.60

8.80

4.80

6.20

5.90

8.60

3.70

6.60

4.30

5.60

6.90

2.40

Overall rank

8

9

12

4

7

6

11

2

9

3

5

10

1

Back to article page