Table 15 Ablation experiments outcomes for AMOMM-BKA on CEC2022 test suite.

From: Adaptive memory-based opposition and midpoint mutation in black winged kite algorithm for global optimization and engineering applications

Functions

Metric

BKA

BOBLBKA

HROBKA

ROBKA

MMBKA

AMOMM-BKA

Fun34

AVG

1.644E+03

1.528E+03

9.394E+03

5.907E+03

3.004E+02

3.000E+02

STD

2.779E+03

6.376E+02

3.278E+03

2.807E+03

6.417E-01

4.424E-02

Fun35

AVG

4.304E+02

4.082E+02

4.070E+02

4.071E+02

4.076E+02

4.042E+02

STD

4.742E+01

1.231E+01

1.371E+00

2.250E+00

1.515E+01

1.299E+01

Fun36

AVG

6.281E+02

6.062E+02

6.137E+02

6.112E+02

6.059E+02

6.035E+02

STD

9.481E+00

4.380E+00

5.268E+00

4.491E+00

5.223E+00

3.299E+00

Fun37

AVG

8.195E+02

8.184E+02

8.338E+02

8.230E+02

8.196E+02

8.174E+02

STD

7.285E+00

7.310E+00

7.698E+00

4.748E+00

4.190E+00

5.864E+00

Fun38

AVG

1.146E+03

9.611E+02

1.386E+03

1.052E+03

1.001E+03

9.483E+02

STD

1.254E+02

4.125E+01

2.639E+02

7.946E+01

6.845E+01

4.388E+01

Fun39

AVG

2.833E+03

2.994E+03

5.163E+03

4.781E+03

3.074E+03

2.681E+03

STD

1.547E+03

8.114E+02

1.451E+03

1.552E+03

1.227E+03

8.724E+02

Fun40

AVG

2.046E+03

2.025E+03

2.024E+03

2.025E+03

2.018E+03

2.024E+03

STD

1.652E+01

3.610E+00

1.501E+00

3.250E+00

1.165E+01

9.047E+00

Fun41

AVG

2.241E+03

2.225E+03

2.226E+03

2.226E+03

2.219E+03

2.218E+03

STD

3.480E+01

4.100E+00

1.504E+00

2.991E+00

6.152E+00

3.945E+00

Fun42

AVG

2.544E+03

2.529E+03

2.529E+03

2.529E+03

2.529E+03

2.529E+03

STD

4.476E+01

6.611E-04

9.090E-04

9.319E-04

9.916E-09

1.726E-11

Fun43

AVG

2.549E+03

2.515E+03

2.517E+03

2.515E+03

2.517E+03

2.518E+03

STD

7.828E+01

1.283E-01

1.273E-01

1.211E-01

1.734E-01

4.437E+01

Fun44

AVG

2.811E+03

2.607E+03

2.692E+03

2.636E+03

2.790E+03

2.674E+03

STD

3.054E+02

8.443E+00

5.233E+01

3.525E+01

1.874E+02

4.927E+01

Fun45

AVG

2.867E+03

2.864E+03

2.871E+03

2.864E+03

2.869E+03

2.864E+03

STD

7.189E+00

1.136E+00

7.552E+00

9.954E-01

6.641E+00

1.111E+00