Table 3 Ablation analysis results of PEAO and its variants on CEC2022.
PEAO-P | PEAO-L | PEAO-PM | PEAO-PL | PEAO | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
F1 | Best | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 |
Mean | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | 3.00E + 02 | |
STD | 1.83E-14 | 1.06E-14 | 0.00E + 00 | 1.83E−14 | 0.00E + 00 | |
F2 | Best | 4.00E + 02 | 4.04E + 02 | 4.00E + 02 | 4.00E + 02 | 4.00E + 02 |
Mean | 4.03E + 02 | 4.05E + 02 | 4.03E + 02 | 4.04E + 02 | 4.03E + 02 | |
STD | 2.26E + 00 | 2.30E + 00 | 2.56E + 00 | 2.04E + 00 | 2.04E + 00 | |
F3 | Best | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 |
Mean | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | 6.00E + 02 | |
STD | 7.02E−06 | 9.67E−14 | 7.52E−07 | 9.44E−14 | 8.18E−14 | |
F4 | Best | 8.03E + 02 | 8.02E + 02 | 8.01E + 02 | 8.03E + 02 | 8.01E + 02 |
Mean | 8.12E + 02 | 8.06E + 02 | 8.08E + 02 | 8.06E + 02 | 8.06E + 02 | |
STD | 5.58E + 00 | 2.77E + 00 | 3.32E + 00 | 4.43E + 00 | 2.77E + 00 | |
F5 | Best | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 |
Mean | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | 9.00E + 02 | |
STD | 6.33E−14 | 0.00E + 00 | 0.00E + 00 | 8.40E−02 | 0.00E + 00 | |
F6 | Best | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 |
Mean | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | 1.80E + 03 | |
STD | 9.98E−01 | 2.16E + 00 | 5.89E−01 | 4.90E + 00 | 5.89E−01 | |
F7 | Best | 2.00E + 03 | 2.00E + 03 | 2.00E + 03 | 2.00E + 03 | 2.00E + 03 |
Mean | 2.01E + 03 | 2.01E + 03 | 2.01E + 03 | 2.01E + 03 | 2.01E + 03 | |
STD | 8.76E + 00 | 9.56E + 00 | 7.68E + 00 | 9.76E + 00 | 7.68E + 00 | |
F8 | Best | 2.20E + 03 | 2.20E + 03 | 2.20E + 03 | 2.20E + 03 | 2.20E + 03 |
Mean | 2.21E + 03 | 2.21E + 03 | 2.21E + 03 | 2.21E + 03 | 2.21E + 03 | |
STD | 7.48E + 00 | 7.17E + 00 | 8.63E + 00 | 6.78E + 00 | 6.78E + 00 | |
F9 | Best | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 |
Mean | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | 2.53E + 03 | |
STD | 0.00E + 00 | 0.00E + 00 | 0.00E + 00 | 0.00E + 00 | 0.00E + 00 | |
F10 | Best | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 |
Mean | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | 2.50E + 03 | |
STD | 3.40E−02 | 4.16E−02 | 6.27E−02 | 5.33E−02 | 3.40E−02 | |
F11 | Best | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 |
Mean | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | 2.60E + 03 | |
STD | 3.04E−13 | 3.68E−13 | 2.67E−13 | 4.31E−13 | 2.67E−13 | |
F12 | Best | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 |
Mean | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | 2.86E + 03 | |
STD | 1.49E + 00 | 1.47E + 00 | 1.84E + 00 | 1.42E + 00 | 1.42E + 00 |