Table 2 Comparison between gene sequencing and MALDI biotyper identification among Legionella species.

From: Identification of Legionella by MALDI Biotyper through three preparation methods and an in-house library comparing phylogenetic and hierarchical cluster results

mip and rpoB gene sequencing identification

L. anisa

36/104

(34.61%)

L. londiniensis

6/104

(5.77%)

L. nautarum

20/104

(19.23%)

L. rubrilucens

31/104

(29.81%)

L. taurinensis

10/104

(9.62%)

L. pneumophila

1/104

(0.96%)

MALDI-TOF MS

DS

EDS

E

DS

EDS

E

DS

EDS

E

DS

EDS

E

DS

EDS

E

DS

EDS

E

Species level

(High confidence score)

35/36

(97.22%)

36/36 (100%)

36/36 (100%)

3/6 (50%)

2/6

(33.33%)

3/6

(50%)

16/20

(80%)

15/20

(75%)

15/20

(75%)

3/31

(9.68%)

5/31 (16.13%)

7/31

(22.58%)

10/10

(100%)

9/10

(90%)

9/10 (90%)

1/1

(100%)

1/1

(100%)

1/1

(100%)

Genus level

(Low confidence score)

1/36 (2.78%)

  

3/6 (50%)

4/6 (66.67%)

3/6 (50%)

4/20 (20%)

5/20 (25%)

5/20 (25%)

25/31 (80.65%)

24/31 (77.42%)

19/31 (61.29%)

 

1/10 (10%)

1/10 (10%)

   

No identification

         

3/31 (9.68%)

2/31 (6.45%)

5/31 (16.13%)