Table 15 Best LightGBM model parameter selections made by each optimizer.

From: Intrusion detection in metaverse environment internet of things systems by metaheuristics tuned two level framework

Approach

rounds

max_depth

Leaves

mcw

ff

bf

msg

\(\lambda\) L1

\(\lambda\) L2

lr

CNN-LGBM-ISA-ChOA

296

9

42

5

8.62E-01

5.15E-01

1.00E-02

1.14E-01

5.52E-01

5.83E-01

CNN-LGBM-ChOA

300

9

45

8

6.73E-01

8.39E-01

2.17E-02

4.88E-03

0.00E+00

3.77E-01

CNN-LGBM-VNS

300

9

45

5

2.90E-01

8.45E-01

1.51E-02

0.00E-00

1.73E+00

5.78E-01

CNN-LGBM-PSO

287

7

41

5

3.91E-01

9.48E-01

1.06E-03

0.00E-00

1.25E+00

9.00E-01

CNN-LGBM-BA

263

7

45

9

9.00E-01

9.67E-01

1.00E-03

1.31E+00

1.12E+00

5.26E-01

CNN-LGBM-ABC

212

10

33

5

6.59E-01

7.87E-01

1.00E-01

0.00E-00

3.52E-01

7.29E-01

CNN-LGBM-WOA

300

9

28

7

9.00E-01

5.00E-01

2.94E-02

1.12E-02

1.53E+00

6.22E-01

CNN-LGBM-RSA

277

8

45

11

6.13E-01

5.06E-01

1.14E-03

0.00E-00

1.99E-01

6.89E-01