Table 10 Evaluation of the ELS according to the characteristics of the disasters and environment.
From: Research on efficient relief logistics planning under massive natural disasters
NR | MDP | DT | MD | ND | ELS | Optimal | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
APSD | AFS | AC | ANF | ACT | APSD | AFS | AC | ANF | ACT | ||||||
Small | 10% | Typhoon | Weak | 574.39 | 83.51 | 34.85 | 3,554 | 34.98 | 25.13 | 87.76 | 35.27 | 3,732 | 36.31 | 2,996 | |
Strong | 604.03 | 73.52 | 34.99 | 3,525 | 34.52 | 25.10 | 77.20 | 35.51 | 3,706 | 35.80 | 3,054 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 540.75 | 93.59 | 31.78 | 3,045 | 34.60 | 24.85 | 98.27 | 32.13 | 3,194 | 36.04 | 2,966 | |||
Strong | 558.89 | 83.57 | 31.87 | 2,959 | 34.89 | 24.79 | 87.71 | 32.37 | 3,107 | 36.10 | 2,986 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 617.42 | 63.27 | 38.20 | 4,094 | 35.11 | 25.07 | 66.29 | 38.71 | 4,297 | 36.45 | 2,962 | |||
Strong | 646.89 | 53.53 | 38.56 | 4,093 | 35.10 | 24.93 | 56.23 | 38.95 | 4,293 | 36.43 | 2,989 | ||||
20% | Typhoon | Weak | 580.39 | 82.60 | 34.88 | 3,536 | 35.46 | 25.09 | 86.72 | 35.46 | 3,710 | 36.72 | 2,965 | ||
Strong | 601.42 | 72.62 | 34.95 | 3,570 | 34.77 | 25.19 | 76.28 | 35.40 | 3,746 | 36.08 | 3,020 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 537.42 | 92.79 | 31.89 | 2,955 | 34.65 | 24.88 | 97.24 | 32.31 | 3,099 | 35.94 | 3,050 | |||
Strong | 561.98 | 82.43 | 31.82 | 2,979 | 35.08 | 24.89 | 86.45 | 32.30 | 3,123 | 36.35 | 3,029 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 622.40 | 62.46 | 38.59 | 4,117 | 35.32 | 25.01 | 65.48 | 39.03 | 4,319 | 36.55 | 2,976 | |||
Strong | 633.10 | 52.74 | 39.02 | 4,106 | 34.86 | 25.05 | 55.27 | 39.55 | 4,318 | 36.12 | 2,971 | ||||
30% | Typhoon | Weak | 582.83 | 81.63 | 34.81 | 3,516 | 35.22 | 25.08 | 85.67 | 35.39 | 3,694 | 36.49 | 3,010 | ||
Strong | 596.48 | 71.37 | 34.95 | 3,528 | 34.75 | 25.07 | 74.94 | 35.32 | 3,702 | 36.10 | 3,014 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 538.65 | 91.65 | 32.07 | 2,991 | 34.89 | 25.14 | 96.18 | 32.60 | 3,134 | 36.34 | 2,999 | |||
Strong | 555.09 | 81.69 | 31.96 | 2,972 | 35.04 | 24.96 | 85.86 | 32.50 | 3,116 | 36.44 | 2,968 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 618.48 | 61.34 | 38.12 | 4,125 | 34.84 | 24.91 | 64.34 | 38.72 | 4,328 | 36.19 | 3,029 | |||
Strong | 642.13 | 51.52 | 38.32 | 4,104 | 34.75 | 25.15 | 54.12 | 38.90 | 4,305 | 36.00 | 2,987 | ||||
Medium | 10% | Typhoon | Weak | 571.33 | 83.43 | 35.16 | 3,676 | 34.76 | 24.96 | 92.23 | 35.76 | 3,867 | 36.21 | 3,014 | |
Strong | 607.90 | 73.43 | 35.22 | 3,736 | 34.94 | 25.01 | 80.91 | 35.68 | 3,919 | 36.25 | 3,004 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 540.45 | 93.57 | 31.90 | 3,122 | 35.11 | 25.07 | 103.09 | 32.48 | 3,290 | 36.44 | 2,915 | |||
Strong | 556.43 | 83.62 | 32.03 | 3,160 | 34.43 | 24.89 | 91.92 | 32.59 | 3,321 | 35.85 | 3,040 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 612.89 | 63.41 | 38.31 | 4,247 | 34.85 | 24.90 | 69.92 | 38.85 | 4,448 | 36.17 | 2,985 | |||
Strong | 642.65 | 53.47 | 38.88 | 4,259 | 34.76 | 25.09 | 58.74 | 39.46 | 4,454 | 35.96 | 2,972 | ||||
20% | Typhoon | Weak | 584.04 | 82.67 | 34.64 | 3,740 | 35.58 | 24.86 | 91.31 | 35.27 | 3,933 | 36.87 | 2,928 | ||
Strong | 600.48 | 72.54 | 34.65 | 3,708 | 35.06 | 24.97 | 79.61 | 35.10 | 3,879 | 36.51 | 3,039 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 551.15 | 92.59 | 31.81 | 3,109 | 35.09 | 25.12 | 102.25 | 32.38 | 3,258 | 36.53 | 3,017 | |||
Strong | 567.38 | 82.46 | 31.98 | 3,144 | 34.99 | 24.98 | 90.56 | 32.57 | 3,300 | 36.22 | 3,049 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 609.29 | 62.43 | 37.93 | 4,231 | 34.92 | 25.06 | 68.70 | 38.54 | 4,432 | 36.21 | 2,995 | |||
Strong | 651.75 | 52.18 | 38.43 | 4,234 | 35.14 | 25.04 | 57.50 | 38.84 | 4,449 | 36.48 | 3,006 | ||||
30% | Typhoon | Weak | 577.38 | 81.37 | 34.79 | 3,704 | 34.91 | 24.98 | 89.67 | 35.44 | 3,880 | 36.34 | 2,972 | ||
Strong | 603.98 | 71.63 | 35.22 | 3,655 | 34.89 | 25.02 | 78.96 | 35.71 | 3,838 | 36.14 | 2,961 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 548.66 | 91.51 | 32.00 | 3,127 | 35.30 | 25.17 | 100.66 | 32.56 | 3,280 | 36.62 | 3,017 | |||
Strong | 558.08 | 81.63 | 31.90 | 3,086 | 34.67 | 24.89 | 89.94 | 32.38 | 3,247 | 36.03 | 2,968 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 627.60 | 61.71 | 38.60 | 4,256 | 35.02 | 24.87 | 68.04 | 39.12 | 4,466 | 36.32 | 3,031 | |||
Strong | 654.26 | 51.72 | 38.98 | 4,259 | 35.11 | 24.89 | 57.00 | 39.44 | 4,478 | 36.33 | 3,042 | ||||
Large | 10% | Typhoon | Weak | 570.63 | 83.57 | 34.46 | 3,832 | 35.23 | 24.79 | 93.86 | 35.21 | 4,011 | 36.53 | 2,953 | |
Strong | 604.53 | 73.39 | 35.02 | 3,792 | 34.69 | 24.89 | 82.49 | 35.46 | 3,977 | 36.05 | 2,973 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 537.21 | 93.16 | 31.88 | 3,212 | 34.99 | 24.98 | 104.93 | 32.36 | 3,375 | 36.29 | 2,946 | |||
Strong | 562.83 | 83.52 | 31.91 | 3,281 | 35.45 | 25.16 | 93.76 | 32.34 | 3,441 | 36.68 | 3,011 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 624.61 | 63.54 | 38.59 | 4,395 | 35.11 | 25.17 | 71.69 | 39.01 | 4,597 | 36.33 | 3,028 | |||
Strong | 633.42 | 53.22 | 38.79 | 4,372 | 34.80 | 24.99 | 59.95 | 39.30 | 4,579 | 36.22 | 2,919 | ||||
20% | Typhoon | Weak | 581.62 | 82.67 | 35.11 | 3,819 | 34.67 | 24.98 | 93.29 | 35.50 | 4,025 | 35.92 | 2,997 | ||
Strong | 597.18 | 72.39 | 35.18 | 3,794 | 34.59 | 24.99 | 81.17 | 35.86 | 3,996 | 35.88 | 2,994 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 545.36 | 92.82 | 31.80 | 3,243 | 35.22 | 25.16 | 104.54 | 32.31 | 3,395 | 36.64 | 3,014 | |||
Strong | 560.66 | 82.35 | 31.78 | 3,264 | 34.77 | 25.07 | 92.84 | 32.21 | 3,430 | 36.08 | 2,919 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 621.66 | 62.32 | 38.64 | 4,385 | 34.89 | 24.80 | 70.18 | 39.11 | 4,614 | 36.21 | 2,999 | |||
Strong | 639.90 | 52.50 | 38.25 | 4,394 | 35.23 | 24.61 | 59.21 | 38.63 | 4,603 | 36.61 | 2,983 | ||||
30% | Typhoon | Weak | 578.08 | 81.41 | 34.67 | 3,818 | 34.98 | 25.04 | 91.86 | 35.01 | 3,995 | 36.37 | 2,995 | ||
Strong | 608.02 | 71.79 | 35.44 | 3,829 | 34.99 | 24.92 | 80.56 | 35.89 | 4,018 | 36.22 | 2,967 | ||||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 547.70 | 91.42 | 31.88 | 3,240 | 35.42 | 25.08 | 103.05 | 32.42 | 3,404 | 36.66 | 3,020 | |||
Strong | 563.39 | 81.51 | 31.86 | 3,217 | 35.45 | 25.12 | 91.85 | 32.43 | 3,382 | 36.88 | 3,035 | ||||
Earthquake | Weak | 624.00 | 61.30 | 38.80 | 4,376 | 35.05 | 25.12 | 68.75 | 39.37 | 4,591 | 36.32 | 2,969 | |||
Strong | 649.87 | 51.61 | 38.67 | 4,374 | 35.21 | 24.97 | 58.28 | 39.20 | 4,584 | 36.60 | 3,000 | ||||
Average | 591.28 | 74.18 | 35.13 | 3,682 | 34.98 | 25.00 | 81.02 | 35.63 | 3,865 | 36.30 | 2,994 | ||||
