Table 6 Evaluation of the DVRA’s performance.
From: Research on efficient relief logistics planning under massive natural disasters
NR | MDP | DT | MD | ND | AAD | DVRA | Optimal | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
APSD (%) | ACT (sec) | AMT (sec) | ALUT (sec) | APSD(%) | ACT(sec) | ||||||
Small | 10% | Typhoon | Weak | 562.44 | 29.35 | 81.85 | 24.55 | 15.93 | 8.85 | 85.75 | 362.82 |
Strong | 575.74 | 37.43 | 69.35 | 24.56 | 16.84 | 7.91 | 72.78 | 374.29 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 517.21 | 30.13 | 95.84 | 25.28 | 15.52 | 8.68 | 98.49 | 365.15 | ||
Strong | 533.38 | 30.66 | 83.24 | 24.38 | 15.78 | 8.44 | 87.41 | 358.77 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 608.39 | 113.71 | 56.86 | 24.94 | 17.31 | 7.53 | 60.12 | 383.96 | ||
Strong | 619.49 | 191.09 | 43.39 | 24.48 | 17.75 | 7.22 | 45.85 | 376.67 | |||
20% | Typhoon | Weak | 554.85 | 30.99 | 80.79 | 24.37 | 15.61 | 8.49 | 84.94 | 347.84 | |
Strong | 587.17 | 40.88 | 68.44 | 24.57 | 16.62 | 8.17 | 72.14 | 368.89 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 544.22 | 24.29 | 94.09 | 24.96 | 15.93 | 8.68 | 97.77 | 371.12 | ||
Strong | 532.95 | 26.67 | 82.64 | 24.75 | 16.09 | 8.72 | 87.08 | 377.55 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 592.92 | 122.82 | 56.45 | 25.71 | 17.32 | 7.87 | 60.02 | 389.00 | ||
Strong | 600.55 | 181.87 | 43.50 | 25.01 | 18.10 | 7.66 | 46.19 | 383.64 | |||
30% | Typhoon | Weak | 548.57 | 28.55 | 80.02 | 24.33 | 16.48 | 8.34 | 84.66 | 377.15 | |
Strong | 559.34 | 43.07 | 68.04 | 24.57 | 16.37 | 8.53 | 72.15 | 359.57 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 532.51 | 28.58 | 92.67 | 24.81 | 15.98 | 8.27 | 97.29 | 369.29 | ||
Strong | 548.06 | 25.72 | 80.91 | 24.67 | 16.17 | 8.60 | 85.50 | 373.17 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 584.76 | 120.71 | 56.04 | 25.12 | 17.11 | 7.86 | 59.90 | 377.79 | ||
Strong | 606.22 | 207.05 | 44.44 | 24.94 | 17.69 | 7.67 | 47.58 | 351.67 | |||
Medium | 10% | Typhoon | Weak | 599.55 | 45.68 | 82.16 | 24.78 | 14.82 | 10.11 | 85.77 | 378.71 |
Strong | 584.36 | 70.22 | 68.59 | 24.79 | 15.46 | 10.02 | 71.79 | 380.20 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 533.13 | 44.43 | 95.60 | 25.04 | 13.76 | 10.57 | 98.51 | 383.46 | ||
Strong | 581.34 | 42.46 | 83.40 | 25.26 | 14.52 | 9.99 | 87.51 | 377.39 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 595.47 | 215.95 | 56.71 | 25.15 | 15.72 | 9.25 | 60.03 | 368.54 | ||
Strong | 661.40 | 331.17 | 42.12 | 25.26 | 16.00 | 9.08 | 44.56 | 370.69 | |||
20% | Typhoon | Weak | 603.44 | 50.82 | 80.12 | 24.72 | 14.68 | 10.08 | 84.57 | 365.65 | |
Strong | 617.93 | 66.53 | 68.28 | 25.47 | 15.02 | 10.27 | 71.92 | 382.27 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 538.68 | 42.07 | 93.96 | 25.08 | 14.26 | 10.03 | 97.96 | 375.87 | ||
Strong | 541.87 | 45.46 | 82.02 | 24.83 | 14.79 | 10.18 | 86.65 | 371.65 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 623.83 | 231.51 | 55.64 | 24.81 | 15.65 | 9.36 | 59.07 | 381.81 | ||
Strong | 660.60 | 332.02 | 42.78 | 25.35 | 16.27 | 9.46 | 45.50 | 372.74 | |||
30% | Typhoon | Weak | 601.12 | 51.69 | 80.07 | 25.00 | 14.99 | 10.31 | 84.55 | 385.38 | |
Strong | 607.75 | 68.80 | 67.47 | 24.75 | 15.28 | 9.79 | 71.51 | 371.97 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 555.82 | 44.86 | 92.19 | 24.46 | 14.15 | 10.32 | 96.88 | 368.21 | ||
Strong | 579.85 | 44.86 | 81.38 | 25.37 | 14.48 | 10.56 | 85.91 | 372.26 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 588.21 | 247.94 | 55.70 | 24.86 | 15.74 | 9.72 | 59.56 | 374.59 | ||
Strong | 655.36 | 333.01 | 42.88 | 25.25 | 16.63 | 8.61 | 45.91 | 377.05 | |||
Large | 10% | Typhoon | Weak | 637.50 | 68.59 | 81.02 | 24.91 | 12.63 | 11.93 | 84.61 | 377.78 |
Strong | 628.09 | 94.01 | 67.75 | 24.94 | 13.92 | 11.01 | 71.15 | 364.19 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 566.42 | 55.94 | 94.57 | 24.91 | 12.19 | 12.20 | 97.98 | 370.26 | ||
Strong | 580.69 | 69.40 | 82.86 | 24.46 | 12.87 | 12.12 | 86.44 | 375.12 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 640.18 | 316.65 | 56.34 | 25.49 | 14.62 | 11.64 | 59.60 | 394.15 | ||
Strong | 667.16 | 452.55 | 41.87 | 25.39 | 15.09 | 11.29 | 44.35 | 377.97 | |||
20% | Typhoon | Weak | 610.27 | 70.04 | 81.23 | 25.00 | 13.11 | 11.92 | 85.63 | 375.27 | |
Strong | 611.93 | 98.07 | 68.06 | 25.66 | 13.83 | 11.55 | 71.93 | 388.01 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 556.77 | 57.33 | 94.17 | 24.66 | 12.68 | 11.91 | 98.03 | 361.11 | ||
Strong | 587.78 | 61.73 | 81.92 | 25.02 | 12.80 | 12.20 | 86.22 | 370.08 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 657.23 | 310.33 | 55.72 | 25.40 | 14.37 | 10.97 | 59.29 | 396.76 | ||
Strong | 674.18 | 463.73 | 42.58 | 25.25 | 15.73 | 10.24 | 45.35 | 382.95 | |||
30% | Typhoon | Weak | 619.23 | 68.90 | 79.56 | 25.11 | 13.11 | 11.69 | 84.14 | 374.97 | |
Strong | 638.64 | 95.44 | 66.93 | 24.98 | 13.71 | 11.57 | 70.91 | 385.34 | |||
Heavy Rainfall | Weak | 543.19 | 65.84 | 92.70 | 25.41 | 13.04 | 11.97 | 97.39 | 368.33 | ||
Strong | 570.45 | 63.53 | 81.18 | 24.51 | 13.12 | 12.45 | 85.90 | 350.66 | |||
Earthquake | Weak | 664.56 | 299.31 | 55.32 | 25.11 | 14.20 | 11.17 | 59.20 | 381.97 | ||
Strong | 665.66 | 468.67 | 43.07 | 24.81 | 15.49 | 10.79 | 46.09 | 356.70 | |||
Average | 593.67 | 125.98 | 70.68 | 24.95 | 15.14 | 9.89 | 74.41 | 373.7 | |||
