Table 1 Literature summary of oil-exporting countries.

From: Oil sector and CO2 emissions in Saudi Arabia: asymmetry analysis

Authors

Region

Major findings

Fan et al. (2019)

Vietnam

Economic development influenced the urbanisation and urbanisation damaged the environment.

Roberts et al. (2019)

Global

Increasing heterogeneity in oil deposits and carbon tax helped in reducing the emissions from oil.

Charfeddine et al. (2018)

Qatar

Bidirectional causality between urbanisation and electricity consumption and unidirectional causality from electricity consumption to economic growth were found.

Mikayilov et al. (2018a)

Azerbaijan

Monotonic and inelastic effect of economic growth on the CO2 emissions was found.

Hasanov et al. (2016)

Oil-exporting countries

Oil price, income, and population age group were significant determinants of energy use.

Hasanov et al. (2019)

Kazakhstan

EKC was not found, and the U-shaped relationship between income and CO2 emissions was observed.

Raggad (2018)

Saudi Arabia

Monotonic effect of income on the CO2 emissions and a positive association between energy usage and CO2 emissions were found. The impact of urbanisation was negative on the CO2 emissions.

Farhani et al. (2014)

MENA including Saudi Arabia

EKC was found in the panel estimates. In the country-specific analysis, EKC was not found in Saudi Arabia, and positive (adverse) effects of energy consumption (trade) were found on the CO2 emissions.

Omri et al. (2015)

MENA including Saudi Arabia

EKC was found in the panel of MENA countries but not in the country-specific estimates of Saudi Arabia. Energy consumption and trade had positive effects on the CO2 emissions in the panel estimates. Urbanisation and energy consumption had a positive impact on CO2 emissions in Saudi Arabia.

Samargandi (2017)

Saudi Arabia

EKC was not found. Industrial and service sectors had positive effects on the CO2 emissions, but the effects of the agriculture sector and technology innovation were found insignificance statistically.

Mahmood et al. (2018)

Saudi Arabia

Inverted U-shaped relationship between income and CO2 emissions and asymmetrical effects of FMD on the CO2 emissions were found.

Alsaedi and Tularam (2020)

Saudi Arabia

The bidirectional relationship between peak load, electricity consumption, and GDP.

Mahmood et al. (2019a)

Saudi Arabia

EKC was validated, and asymmetrical effects of the agriculture sector were found on the CO2 emissions.