Table 2 Quality appraisal.
No | Questions for Quality Appraisal | 1. Cui et al. (2019) | 2. Czar et al. (2021) | 3. Loke et al. (2015) | 4. Salazar et al. (2021) | 5. Eichelberger et al. (2017) | 6. Noreen et al. (2019) | 7. Xiao et al. (2015) | 8. Xiao, Porto, and Mason (2020) | 9. Amonhaemanon and Vora-Sitta (2020) | 10. Cheak-Zamora et al. (2017) | 11. Collins-Odders-White (2021) | 12. Demakis et al. (2018) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Does the study describe the primary research objective? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) |
2 | Does the study define financial capability? | No (0) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) |
3 | Does the study determine a financial capability measurement? | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) |
4 | Does the study state the financial capability determinants? | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
5 | Does the study clearly define young adults? | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) |
6 | Is the sampling strategy relevant to the research question? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
7 | Does the paper thoroughly explain the sampling procedure? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
8 | Does the study indicate the source of the dataset? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
9 | Does the study use appropriate statistical analysis to answer the research question? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
10 | Does the study define the measurement of independent variables? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) |
11 | Does the study clearly present the results and findings? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
12 | Does the study identify research limitations? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
| Â | Total Score | 9 | 11.5 | 9 | 11.5 | 7 | 8 | 11.5 | 11.5 | 7 | 8 | 9.5 | 11 |
| Â | Paper category | Good | Excellent | Good | Excellent | Good | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Good | Good | Good | Excellent |
No | Questions for Quality Appraisal | 13. Fan (2021) | 14. Friedline and West (2016) | 15. Huang et al. (2015) | 16. Johnson and Sherraden (2007) | 17. Lebaron et al. (2018) | 18. Serido et al. (2013) | 19. Sherraden and Grinstein-Weiss (2015) | 20. Sherraden et al. (2011) | 21. West and Friedline (2016) | 22. Zhu (2020) | 23. Zhu (2018) | 24. Zhu and Chou (2018) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Does the study describe the primary research objective? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
2 | Does the study define financial capability? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) |
3 | Does the study determine a financial capability measurement? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | No (0) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
4 | Does the study state the financial capability determinants? | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
5 | Does the study clearly define young adults? | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) |
6 | Is the sampling strategy relevant to the research question? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) |
7 | Does the paper thoroughly explain the sampling procedure? | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | Partly (0.5) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
8 | Does the study indicate the source of the dataset? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) |
9 | Does the study use appropriate statistical analysis to answer the research question? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) |
10 | Does the study define the measurement of independent variables? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | No (0) | Yes (1) | No (0) | No (0) | Partly (0.5) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) |
11 | Does the study clearly present the results and findings? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Partly (0.5) |
12 | Does the study identify research limitations? | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | No (0) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) | Yes (1) |
| Â | Total Score | 10.5 | 11 | 10.5 | 4.5 | 8 | 10.5 | 4 | 8 | 11 | 11.5 | 11.5 | 8 |
| Â | Paper category | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Fair | Good | Excellent | Fair | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Good |
