Table 5 The estimated results of direct, indirect and total effect.
adjW | W5 | W6 | W7 | ecoW | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fixed | Random | Fixed | Random | Fixed | Random | Fixed | Random | Fixed | Random | |
\({\bar{{\rm{M}}}\left({\rm{F}}\right)}_{{\rm{direct}}}\) | −0.0061+ (−1.5779) | −0.0059+ (−1.5441) | −0.0098*** (−2.5632) | −0.0097*** (−2.6116) | −0.0116*** (−3.0582) | −0.0109*** (−2.9637) | −0.0079** (−2.3068) | −0.0070** (−2.0219) | −0.0093** (−2.4174) | −0.0089** (−2.3665) |
\({\bar{{\rm{M}}}\left({\rm{D}}\right)}_{{\rm{direct}}}\) | −0.0070 (−0.4008) | −0.0037 (−0.2073) | −0.0354** (−2.2254) | −0.0318* (−1.9209) | 0.0029 (0.1928) | 0.0055 (0.3469) | −0.0151 (−1.0317) | −0.0152 (−1.0108) | 0.0176 (1.2456) | 0.0235* (1.6543) |
\({\bar{{\rm{M}}}\left({\rm{F}}\right)}_{{\rm{indirect}}}\) | −0.0285** (−2.0854) | −0.0263** (−2.1491) | −0.0453*** (−3.7539) | −0.0426*** (−4.0907) | −0.1050*** (−7.1059) | −0.0970*** (−7.6702) | −0.1157*** (−7.0199) | −0.1069*** (−7.3907) | −0.0490*** (−5.1949) | −0.0450*** (−5.2999) |
\({\bar{{\rm{M}}}\left({\rm{D}}\right)}_{{\rm{indirect}}}\) | 0.1923*** (4.8016) | 0.1773*** (4.7978) | 0.3167*** (10.2458) | 0.3019*** (10.1508) | 0.3062*** (9.6315) | 0.2890*** (9.4694) | 0.3929*** (10.6224) | 0.3714*** (11.0770) | −0.0930** (−2.4262) | −0.0753** (−2.1548) |
\({\bar{{\rm{M}}}\left({\rm{F}}\right)}_{{\rm{total}}}\) | −0.0346** (−2.1451) | −0.0323** (−2.2044) | −0.0551*** (−3.8868) | −0.0524*** (−4.3092) | −0.1166*** (−6.9625) | −0.1079*** (−7.6141) | −0.1236*** (−6.9437) | −0.1140*** (−7.2536) | −0.0583*** (−5.1496) | −0.0539*** (−5.4564) |
\({\bar{{\rm{M}}}\left({\rm{D}}\right)}_{{\rm{total}}}\) | 0.1853*** (5.0523) | 0.1735*** (5.4199) | 0.2813*** (9.8298) | 0.2702*** (10.3579) | 0.3091*** (10.2456) | 0.2945*** (10.7561) | 0.3778*** (10.8247) | 0.3562*** (11.7281) | −0.0754 (−1.6381) | −0.0518 (−1.2586) |