Table 2 The calculated unrelaxed surface energies (Es), vacancy formation energies (\({E}_{{{\rm{v}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\)), interstitial formation energies (\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\)), and unstable (γusf) and stable stacking fault energies (γsf), as well as grain boundary energies of low Miller index tilt boundaries for FCC Ni using DP-Ni, in comparison with DFT results, available experimental data, and selected interatomic potentials
From: An accurate and transferable machine learning interatomic potential for nickel
Property | DFT | Expt. | DP | EAM | MEAM_2021 | MEAM_2015 | qSNAP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Es{111} (J/m2) | 1.919 | 2.240a | 1.958 | 1.636 | 1.815 | 1.630 | 1.938 |
Es{221} (J/m2) | 2.210 | 2.259 | 1.924 | 2.164 | 1.965 | 2.230 | |
Es{110} (J/m2) | 2.343 | 2.357 | 2.056 | 2.367 | 2.172 | 2.356 | |
Es{211} (J/m2) | 2.279 | 2.323 | 1.970 | 2.222 | 2.021 | 2.280 | |
Es{210} (J/m2) | 2.463 | 2.488 | 2.181 | 2.526 | 2.321 | 2.472 | |
Es{100} (J/m2) | 2.239 | 2.223 | 1.884 | 2.220 | 2.088 | 2.254 | |
\({E}_{{{\rm{v}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\) (eV) | 1.424 | 1.400–1.800b | 1.236 | 1.598 | 1.539 | 1.509 (1.41) | 1.465 (1.49) |
\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\langle 100\rangle\) dumbbell (eV) | 4.048 | - | 4.184 | 4.885c | 4.253 | 4.531 | 4.118 |
\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\langle 111\rangle\) dumbbell (eV) | 4.664 | - | 4.892 | 6.920 | 4.765 | 5.508 | 4.751 |
\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\langle 110\rangle\) dumbbell (eV) | 4.828 | - | 4.614 | 5.786 | 4.664 | 5.103 | 4.769 |
\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\) Crowdion (eV) | 4.826 | - | 4.614 | 5.114 | 4.669 | 5.112 | 4.788 |
\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\) Octahedral (eV) | 4.229 | - | 4.421 | ⊛ | 4.465 | ⊛ | 4.460 |
\({E}_{{{\rm{i}}}}^{{{\rm{f}}}}\) Tetrahedral (eV) | 4.670 | - | 4.986 | 6.920 | 5.085 | 5.508 | ⊛ |
γusf 〈110〉 (mJ/m2) | 766.6 | - | 801.6 | 924.3 | 746.9 | 898.2 | 789.9 |
γusf 〈112〉 (mJ/m2) | 280.4 | - | 301.9 | 365.6 | 285.4 | 423.6 | 275.5 |
γsf 〈112〉 (mJ/m2) | 135.9 | 125d | 126.8 | 125.2 | −26.9 | 60.0 | 52.2 |
\(\Sigma 3\,[1\bar{1}0](111)\) (mJ/m2) | 68.03 | - | 63.50 | 63.46 | −13.45 | 30.09 | 26.53 |
\(\Sigma 3\,[1\bar{1}0](112)\) (mJ/m2) | 896.03 | - | 893.67 | 1064.03 | 782.53 | 960.66 | 908.44 |
\(\Sigma 5\,[100](0\bar{2}1)\) (mJ/m2) | 1288.75 | - | 1310.72 | 1564.08 | 1372.11 | 1421.66 | 1339.00 |
\(\Sigma 7\,[\bar{1}\bar{1}\bar{1}](3\bar{2}\bar{1})\) (mJ/m2) | 1234.31 | - | 1212.57 | 1471.91 | 1210.14 | 1395.51 | 1286.36 |
\(\Sigma 9\,[\bar{1}10](22\bar{1})\) (mJ/m2) | 1120.58 | - | 1103.69 | 1368.13 | 1148.89 | 1258.83 | 1157.30 |
\(\Sigma 11\,[1\bar{1}0](113)\) (mJ/m2) | 454.23 | - | 440.81 | 531.15 | 420.36 | 518.89 | 464.21 |