Table 2 One-way ANOSIM comparing physiological profiles of non-bleached and bleached coral ramets within each treatment for each species-site combination in December 2014, June 2015, and November 2015

From: Ocean acidification does not prolong recovery of coral holobionts from natural thermal stress in two consecutive years

Species, site

Date

Overall model

Control non-bleached vs. bleached

Fed non-bleached vs. bleached

OA non-bleached vs. bleached

OA+Fed non-bleached vs. bleached

Montipora capitata Kāneʻohe Bay

Dec 2014

R = 0.094

p = 0.022

R = 0.268

p = 0.040

R = 0.276

p = 0.008

R = 0.020

p = 0.341

R = 0.252

p = 0.040

June 2015

R = 0.307

p = 0.001

R = 0.397

p = 0.009

R = 0.654

p = 0.002

R = 0.368

p = 0.016

R = 0.144

p = 0.145

 

Nov

2015

R = 0.085

p = 0.158

R = 0.091

p = 0.286

R = −0.026

p = 0.518

R = 0.185

p = 0.143

R = −0.208

p = 0.821

Montipora capitata Waimānalo Bay

Dec 2014

R = −0.054

p = 0.875

R = 0.152

p = 0.143

R = −0.044

p = 0.627

R = 0.000

p = 0.444

R = −0.169

p = 0.929

June 2015

R = 0.068

p = 0.057

R = 0.183

p = 0.076

R = −0.141

p = 0.922

R = 0.170

p = 0.063

R = −0.099

p = 0.751

 

Nov 2015

R = 0.283

p = 0.005

R = 0.855

p = 0.048

R = −0.148

p = 0.800

R = 1.000

p = 0.250

R = 0.241

p = 0.200

Porites compressa Kāneʻohe Bay

Dec 2014

R = 0.237

p = 0.001

R = 0.031

p = 0.365

R = 0.525

p = 0.016

R = 0.519

p = 0.016

R = 0.417

p = 0.057

June 2015

R = 0.072

p = 0.087

*

R = 0.139

p = 0.110

R = −0.067

p = 0.589

R = 0.291

p = 0.030

 

Nov 2015

*

*

*

*

*

Porites compressa Waimānalo Bay

Dec 2014

R = 0.301

p = 0.001

R = 0.481

p = 0.016

R = 0.446

p = 0.018

R = 0.336

p = 0.032

R = 0.513

p = 0.040

June 2015

R = 0.076

p = 0.164

*

R = −0.231

p = 0.839

*

R = 0.313

p = 0.214

 

Nov 2015

*

*

*

*

*

  1. ANOSIM models included total lipids, endosymbiont cell density, Contribution of Total carbon to Animal Respiration (CTAR), calcification, and tissue biomass. R = global R value. * = sample size too small (due to mortality; see Supplementary Table 4) for ANOSIM. All models were run with 999 permutations.