Table 2 Summary of optical-sensing methodologies.

From: Advancements in photoacoustic detection techniques for biomedical imaging

Acoustic detection methodology

Bandwidth

Application/imaging target

Key features

References

Fabry-Perot interferometer

39 and 22 MHz

Blood filled tubes of diameters ranging from 62 to 300 μm

Spatial resolutions of 38 μm (lateral) and 15 μm (vertical) 

Zhang et al.108

30 MHz

In-vivo human fingertip vessels

Mean FWHM of 300 μm

14 × 14 × 14-mm volume over 90 s

Plumb et al.109

20 MHz

In-vivo mouse

Adaptive optics increases PA signal by 3.5 times.

Czuchnowski et al.110

110 and 75 MHz

N/A

Total-internal-reflection mechanism

Jiang et al.111

35 MHz

Ex-vivo mouse abdominal organs

Spatial resolutions of 70 μm (lateral) and 28 μm (vertical) 

Ansari et al.112

Fiber Bragg grating sensor

N/A

In-vivo rectal inflammation Hb & sO2 monitoring

125-μm sensor aperture size

Spatial resolutions of 7.4 μm

Liang et al.116

200 MHz

In-vivo mouse ear

Spatial resolutions of 25 μm

Hazan et al.117

160 MHz

Ex-vivo mouse ear

10.1-μm sensor aperture size

Spatial resolutions of 14 μm (lateral) and 8.5 μm (vertical) 

La et al.118

10 MHz

In-vivo mouse ear, brain

Transparent microfiber loop

Ma et al.119

Microring resonator (MRR)

23 MHz

Ex-vivo mouse brain and in-vivo mouse ear and tadpole

Spatial resolutions of 114 μm (lateral) and 57 μm (axial) 

Imaging depth of 8 mm

CzaplewskiDavid et al.121

166 and 100 MHz

In-vivo brain monitoring

A disposable US-sensing chronic cranial window by integrating a transparent MRR

Li et al.122

Plano-concave resonator

55 MHz

In-vivo mouse ear

Spatial resolutions of 94.2 μm (lateral) and 65.9 μm (axial) 

Guggenheim et al.123

20 MHz

Ex vivo swine esophagus

Spatial resolutions of 120 μm (lateral) and 45 μm (axial) 

Lewis-Thompson et al.124

Remote sensing

N/A

In-vivo mouse ear

Real-time in-vivo oxygen saturation monitoring

Bell et al.127

Tumor cell cultures and excised tissue samples

Spatial resolutions of 0.7 μm

Nathaniel et al.128

Human breast tissue

Spatial resolutions of 1.2 μm

Abbasi et al.129

Human epidermal, pancreatic, and tonsil tissues

Spatial resolutions of 1.2 μm

Abbasi et al.130

Human breast, gastrointestinal, and tonsil tissues

Spatial resolutions of 1.2 μm (lateral) and 7.3 μm (axial) 

Abbasi et al.131

Human prostate tissue

Fresh murine liver tissue

Rapid voice-coil stage scanning

Spatial resolutions of <0.5 μm

Cikaluk et al.132

Mouse heart, kidney, and liver tissues

Porcine bronchial tissue

Elastography utilizing photoacoustic remote sensing

Yuan et al.133