Table 1 Baseline characteristics and signs and symptoms.

From: Hard-flaccid syndrome: a systematic review of aetiopathophysiology, clinical presentation and management

Author, year

Country

Study type

Number of cases

Age (years)

Duration

Erectile symptoms

Penile symptoms

Ejaculatory symptoms

Perineal/prostate/pelvic symptoms

Urinary symptoms

Psychological symptoms

Other symptoms

Potential cause

Clinical examination

Pang et al. [15]

China

Case report

3

29

4 years (progressed past 4 months)

ED, decreased libido

Penile pain, glans coldness and numbness

No

Perineal pain

Mixed LUTS (frequency, urgency, weak stream, straining)

Anxiety

None

Aggressive masturbation, psychological, RLT

Shrunken penis. Tenderness in penile base. Soft glans

    

29

3.5 months

ED, decreased libido

Semi-rigid penis, soft/numb glans

Not ejaculated since onset of symptoms

Penile and perineal “tightness”

None

Anxiety

None

Penile skin abrasion from shaving, psychological, RLT, TEAT

Firm penis, soft glans, dorsal mid shaft scar tissue

Gul et al. [2]

Turkey

Case series

4

34

3 months

ED, decreased libido

Decreased sensitivity and coldness of glans

Painful ejaculation

NR

NR

Anxiety

None

Aggressive masturbation, marijuana

Hardness right base of penis

    

26

3 months

ED

Soft and cold glans

NR

NR

NR

Anxiety

None

Trauma during sexual intercourse

Unremarkable

    

31

3.5 months

ED

NR

NR

NR

Weak urinary stream

NR

None

Jelqing, aggressive masturbation, history of PD

PD: Tenderness in the proximal penile crura, dorsal penile plaque

    

22

2 days

ED, decreased libido

Numb or stinging

NR

NR

NR

NR

None

Jelqing, aggressive masturbation

Unremarkable

Nico et al. [9]

USA

Case report (congress abstract)

1

16

“several months”

“HFS associated symptoms”

Penile and testicular pain and numbness

NR

NR

NR

NR

None

Masturbation

NR

Sullivan et al. [17]

USA

Congress abstract

88

Mean 28 (SD, 12)

Mean 14 (SD, 20)

ED (100%)

NR

NR

NR

NR

66 (75%) depression or anxiety

NR

NR

Hypertonic flaccid penis, normal neurology

Goldstein and Komisaruk, [4]

USA

Case report

1

18

4 months

ED and HFS

Decreased penis and glans sensation. Smaller, firmer, painful flaccid penis

NR

NR

NR

Depression

None

Lumbar disc protrusion with annular tear

Firm flaccid penis, abnormal neurogenital testing

Billis et al. [8]

Greece

Case report

1

30

6 months

ED, decreased libido

Pain in the base of penis, changes in penile shape

None

Perineal pain, coldness and dysethesia, stiffness, coldness and dysethesia in pelvic floor muscles

LUTS: pain during urination, incomplete bladder emptying, increased urinary frequency

Anxious, worried, interrupted sexual and physical activity

None

Intense sexual intercourse

Tightness in abdominal and external perineal muscles on palpation. Tightness and pain in posterior pelvic floor muscles on DRE

Yazar et al. [7]

USA

Case report

1

36

NR

ED, decreased libido

“sensory issues”, penile pain

NR

Perineal and pelvic pain

NR

NR

None

Skin stretching exercises induced pain

Unremarkable

Goldstein et al. [16]

USA

Congress abstract

21

Mean 28 (range 19–42)

NR

NR

NR

NR

NR

NR

NR

38% had low back pain and lower extremity sciatica

Lumbosacral annular tears

NR

  1. DRE digital rectal examination; Erectile dysfunction; HFS hard-flaccid syndrome, LUTS lower urinary tract symptoms, PD peyronie’s disease, NR not reported, RLT red light therapy, TEAT thread embedding acupuncture therapy.