Table 2 Differentially methylated regions (DMRs, Šidák p-value < 0.01) associated with asthma at 6 years among infants hospitalized for bronchiolitis (n = 506)

From: Epigenomic and proteomic analyses provide insights into early-life immune regulation and asthma development in infants

DMRs

(chromosome:position)

Width

(bp)

N of CpGs

Šidák

p-value

Nearest genes

Modela

Direction of effectb

Overlap with promoter

Distance to TSS (bp)c

Evidence for open chromatind

Statistically significant interaction by rhinovirus infectione

chr1:19969931-19970337

407

10

1.61 × 10−5

NBL1

both

+

No

28

No

No

chr1:46668513-46668840

328

5

7.10 × 10−4

POMGNT1

LRT-2df

+

No

17,137

Yes

No

chr1:94057512-94057789

278

7

4.24 × 10−3

BCAR3-AS1

linear

-

Yes

0

Yes

n/a

chr1:247681297-247681766

470

6

4.27 × 10−3

GCSAML

linear

+

No

10,903

Yes

n/a

chr3:48632568-48633059

492

8

4.23 × 10−6

COL7A1

both

-

Yes

0

No

No

chr5:78365647-78365830

184

7

1.75 × 10−2

BHMT2

LRT-2df

-

No

100

No

No

chr5:135416029-135416613

585

9

2.76 × 10−5

VTRNA2-1

linear

-

Yes

0

Yes

n/a

chr6:26225246-26225407

162

7

1.97 × 10−5

HIST1H3E

linear

-

Yes

0

No

n/a

chr6:28058724-28058973

250

8

1.17 × 10−9

ZSCAN12P1

LRT-2df

-

No

139

Yes

Yes

chr6:28129313-28129656

344

9

8.32 × 10−5

ZKSCAN8P1

both

+

Yes

0

Yes

No

chr6:42927940-42928200

261

9

7.22 × 10−8

GNMT

both

-

Yes

−300

Yes

Yes

chr7:95025855-95026248

394

14

2.20 × 10−4

PON3

both

+

Yes

−168

Yes

No

chr7:150644459-150644866

408

5

1.10 × 10−3

KCNH2

both

+

No

8051

No

No

chr8:144631768-144631921

154

5

8.49 × 10−4

GSDMD

LRT-2df

+

No

−3636

Yes

Yes

chr10:131989303-131989849

547

6

7.38 × 10−6

GLRX3

linear

-

No

54,664

No

n/a

chr11:2890258-2890725

468

24

6.86 × 10−7

KCNQ1DN

linear

-

Yes

−538

No

n/a

chr11:2920052-2920414

363

7

1.52 × 10−3

SLC22A18AS

LRT-2df

+

No

4761

Yes

Yes

chr12:44152565-44152940

376

9

3.46 × 10−5

IRAK4; PUS7L

linear

+

Yes

0

Yes

n/a

chr13:114103452-114103796

345

7

2.41 × 10−5

ADPRHL1

both

-

Yes

0

Yes

No

chr15:23810334-23810861

528

7

1.59 × 10−4

MKRN3

LRT-2df

-

Yes

0

Yes

No

chr15:93652578-93653048

471

5

4.20 × 10−7

RGMA

linear

+

No

−20,135

No

n/a

chr15:101389974-101390350

377

5

3.99 × 10−4

ALDH1A3

LRT-2df

-

No

−29,659

Yes

Yes

chr16:66400320-66400599

280

8

5.17 × 10−5

CDH5

both

+

Yes

0

No

No

chr16:67233432-67233983

552

7

1.32 × 10−5

ELMO3

LRT-2df

-

No

20

No

No

chr17:6899085-6899758

674

12

1.31 × 10−13

ALOX12

both

+

Yes

0

No

No

chr17:9862752-9863081

330

10

9.06 × 10−3

GAS7

LRT-2df

-

Yes

0

Yes

Yes

chr17:38935747-38936092

346

5

2.50 × 10−4

KRT27

LRT-2df

+

No

2694

Yes

Yes

chr17:47571835-47572132

298

5

8.26 × 10−3

NGFR

both

+

Yes

−523

Yes

No

chr18:77623282-77623598

317

7

6.08 × 10−3

KCNG2

linear

+

Yes

−70

No

n/a

chr19:45504242-45504516

275

6

2.69 × 10−3

RELB

LRT-2df

-

Yes

−191

Yes

No

chr19:49198900-49199234

335

5

1.71 × 10−4

FUT2

LRT-2df

+

Yes

0

No

No

chr21:37915044-37915391

348

10

8.64 × 10−4

CLDN14

both

+

Yes

0

No

No

chr22:44568725-44568913

189

6

7.20 × 10−3

PARVG

LRT-2df

+

Yes

0

Yes

No

  1. Genome build: GRCh37/hg19. The DMRs were identified by the comb-p method based on the results of linear regression or LRT-2df. A region was identified as a DMR if it had a Šidák p-value < 0.01 and at least 5 CpG sites.
  2. bp base pair, DMR differentially methylated regions, n/a not applied, TSS transcription starting site, LRT-2df likelihood ratio test with 2 degree of freedom.
  3. aStatistical model in which the DMR was discovered: “linear” represents linear regression without accounting for interaction between asthma and rhinovirus infection; “LRT-2df” represents 2 degree of freedom likelihood ratio test accounting for interaction between asthma and rhinovirus infection; “both” represents that the DMR was identified by both models (in such case, results with more CpG sites were presented).
  4. bDistance to transcription starting site: a negative number means the DMR is upstream from the TSS; a positive number means the DMR is downstream from the TSS.
  5. cDirection of effect was obtained from linear regression or LRT-2df for the main effect of asthma. A + represents higher methylation in asthma cases compared to non-cases among infants without rhinovirus infection; a – represents lower methylation level in asthma cases compared to non-cases among infants without rhinovirus infection. In the case when the direction of effect was inconsistent across CpG sites within a DMR, we took the direction of the average of coefficients across the CpG sites.
  6. dEvidence for open chromatin was obtained by single cell ATAC-seq peak in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from a healthy donor.
  7. eFor DMRs identified by LRT-2df, we obtained the nominal p-value for the interaction term asthma*rhinovirus infection. A “Yes” represents that interaction-p < 0.05 for more than half of the CpG sites in that DMR. Gene names are italicized.