Fig. 3: Development of confirmed tuberculosis among participants with differing subcategories of uncertain and stable X-ray findings, stratified by the time period of follow-up.
From: Prognostic value of an abnormal chest X-ray result in predicting the development of tuberculosis

Cox proportional hazards models show adjusted hazard ratios for the development of confirmed tuberculosis among participants with differing subcategories of uncertain and stable chest X-ray findings. Models are adjusted for age, sex, body mass index, and prior tuberculosis. The unit of study is the individual participant; all data points represent biological replicates (n = 183,382 independent subjects across all groups). The screening time period occurred from March 1 to October 31, 2020. The total follow-up time period was defined as November 1, 2020–October 31, 2022. Referent category are persons with no abnormal X-ray findings (n = 155,833) at the baseline mass screening visit. Precise sample sizes for each subgroup are as follows: Uncertain, non-patchy lesions (n = 4002); Uncertain, patchy lesion (n = 5243); Stable, fibrous lesion (n = 9290); Stable, sclerotic lesion (n = 2920); Stable, Calcification (n = 4277). To account for any undiagnosed, early tuberculosis patients that may have been diagnosed in year 1 of follow-up, a secondary follow-up period with a one year lead-in time was analyzed. This time period began > 1 year after completion of screening and ran from November 1, 2021–October 31, 2022. Referent category are persons with no abnormal X-ray findings (n = 154,447) at the secondary follow-up period. Precise sample sizes for each subgroup are as follows: Uncertain, non-patchy lesions (n = 3819); Uncertain, patchy lesion (n = 5202); Stable, fibrous lesion (n = 9080); Stable, sclerotic lesion (n = 2857); Stable, Calcification (n = 4163).Error bars represent the 95% confidence intervals (CI).