Table 2 Experimental results of evaluation across different flight phases

From: Multi-horizon flight trajectory prediction enabled by time-frequency wavelet transform

Phase

Method

Horizon

MAE↓

MAPE(%)↓

RMSE↓

MDE↓

   

Lon

Lat

Alt

Lon

Lat

Alt

Lon

Lat

Alt

 

Cruise

FlightBERT++

1

0.0015

0.0015

0.02

0.0014

0.0059

0.0028

0.0051

0.0127

0.19

0.15

3

0.0028

0.0027

0.05

0.0026

0.0102

0.0056

0.0077

0.0144

0.45

0.25

9

0.0063

0.0059

0.14

0.0058

0.0226

0.0155

0.0153

0.0214

2.03

0.56

15

0.0094

0.0088

0.21

0.0087

0.0335

0.0214

0.0215

0.0281

4.84

0.84

WTFTP+

1

0.0012

0.0012

0.32

0.0011

0.0046

0.0349

0.0035

0.0078

0.48

0.11

3

0.0022

0.0021

0.53

0.0020

0.0081

0.0575

0.0056

0.0107

0.93

0.19

9

0.0055

0.0052

1.48

0.0051

0.0195

0.1603

0.0140

0.0170

3.78

0.48

15

0.0098

0.0088

2.84

0.0091

0.0332

0.3078

0.0252

0.0248

7.85

0.83

Takeoff/Climb

FlightBERT++

1

0.0028

0.0027

5.43

0.0026

0.0100

1.22

0.0044

0.0045

7.59

0.26

3

0.0056

0.0057

10.52

0.0053

0.0208

2.19

0.0093

0.0101

15.34

0.53

9

0.0129

0.0141

22.76

0.0123

0.0516

4.10

0.0212

0.0254

33.49

1.26

15

0.0194

0.0203

32.74

0.0183

0.0745

5.27

0.0331

0.0347

47.02

1.83

WTFTP+

1

0.0019

0.0021

3.31

0.0018

0.0074

0.68

0.0029

0.0032

4.69

0.18

3

0.0040

0.0043

6.29

0.0038

0.0154

1.22

0.0068

0.0075

9.29

0.37

9

0.0111

0.0124

13.39

0.0105

0.0449

2.23

0.0215

0.0249

19.54

1.05

15

0.0193

0.0214

19.79

0.0182

0.0778

2.94

0.0379

0.0450

29.09

1.83

Approach/Descent

FlightBERT++

1

0.0016

0.0026

2.79

0.0015

0.0093

0.57

0.0032

0.0056

4.60

0.21

3

0.0033

0.0048

5.43

0.0032

0.0171

1.13

0.0071

0.0104

9.04

0.39

9

0.0104

0.0110

15.03

0.0098

0.0389

3.36

0.0249

0.0226

23.94

0.99

15

0.0170

0.0165

24.11

0.0161

0.0578

6.04

0.0395

0.0313

36.87

1.52

WTFTP+

1

0.0013

0.0013

1.90

0.0012

0.0046

0.40

0.0023

0.0022

2.95

0.12

3

0.0028

0.0027

3.89

0.0026

0.0093

0.85

0.0059

0.0050

6.51

0.24

9

0.0094

0.0075

11.07

0.0089

0.0260

2.59

0.0218

0.0143

17.61

0.75

15

0.0176

0.0130

17.68

0.0167

0.0450

4.59

0.0364

0.0236

26.83

1.34

  1. The symbol definitions are consistent with Table 1.
  2. The bold values denote the best performance on the corresponding metric.