Table 9 Robust test.

From: Nonlinear relationship between intellectual property protection and renewable energy innovation in 27 countries

 

(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

 

Omit control variable

DCCE

FGLS

DK standard errors

Exclude the influence of outliers

IPP

0.824a (0.28)

6.534b (2.92)

0.588a (0.07)

0.927a (0.17)

0.631b (0.26)

IPP2

−0.085a (0.02)

−0.390b (0.17)

−0.039a (0.01)

−0.099a (0.01)

−0.075a (0.02)

FDI

−0.004 (0.00)

−0.011 (0.02)

0.001c (0.00)

−0.002 (0.01)

−0.001 (0.00)

Fiscal

0.262a (0.03)

0.033 (0.05)

0.043a (0.01)

0.285a (0.02)

0.288a (0.02)

Trade

0.031a (0.00)

−0.002 (0.01)

−0.004a (0.00)

0.034a (0.01)

0.033a (0.00)

IQ

−0.328a (0.10)

    

constant

−0.328 (1.49)

−28.062b (12.81)

0.698b (0.28)

−5.806a (0.70)

−2.881a (1.03)

Fixed effect

YES

   

YES

N

540

540

540

540

500

R2

0.842

   

0.852

adj. R2

0.832

   

0.843

  1. Standard errors in parentheses.
  2. cp < 0.1, bp < 0.05, ap < 0.01.