Copper-based catalysts, especially the so-called oxide-derived copper, are capable of producing multicarbon species from electrochemical CO2 reduction. However, little is known about their active sites despite intensive research efforts. Now, Lum and Ager show that oxide-derived copper catalysts have three distinct product-specific sites for the formation of C2+ chemicals, unlike polycrystalline copper or (111)- and (100)-oriented copper films which show no evidence of product specific sites.